Angelo's Pizza Reviews Summary

Atmosphere & Ambience

Pros:

• "More than I expected, and the atmosphere was nice too."
• "The patio area is so nice, I recommend that when you visit you sit outside."
• "Atmosphere is laid back and now we’re ready to go back out and fight the crowds!"
• "Very pleasant atmosphere in the restaurant with nice view of the brick ovens used to fire the pizzas."
• "A very warm atmosphere, wonderful staff and nice environment."
• "The atmosphere of the place is nice and the decorations are beautiful."
• "Great atmosphere."

Cons:

• "One complaint I have is that it is way too hot upstairs which did make it a little uncomfortable."
• "The music didn't match the ambience they were aiming to create so that could be improved."
• "The restaurant has a refreshingly quiet atmosphere and it is a nice break from the noisy times square."
• "However the ladies' room was so tiny! I could've barely moved!"
• "I just wanted to enjoy some food downtown and to be stared at the whole time made me feel very uncomfortable."
• "The tip was changed in the credit card charge after we left."
• "But service is horrible. We arrived at 3:38, no one welcomed us, until 4:00 pm."

Service

Pros:

• "Service was agreat. Our waitress was friendly and helpful."
• "Our service was fast."
• "Customer service was great and we were seated quickly."
• "Anyway, the service was great, our waitress was very attentive."
• "Staff was super friendly and attentive."
• "The staff is very nice as well."
• "The staff was friendly and there is plenty of room for families."

Cons:

• "The staff look like they hate their jobs, and our waiter seemed mad that all we ordered was pizza."
• "The staff weren’t not friendly but not friendly either if that makes sense."
• "He never came back to our table until I went to ask for our bill."
• "The main waiter was very unwelcoming, curt, very unprofessional."
• "The service was lousy. We were served water only ONCE on a very hot day."
• "Service was bad and we got simple drinks, two alcoholic and two normal, it took 7 minutes to get them to us."
• "The service was inattentive despite few customers and ample staff literally standing around doing nothing for long stretches."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The combination of fresh mozzarella, a light red sauce and fresh pepperoni's, all served on a well baked crust, makes for a good pizza."
• "Stop what you're doing and eat pizza here. It is delicious!"
• "The ravioli with pesto were delicious."
• "The best NY style pizza I've ever had, possibly the best pizza I've ever had period."
• "Pizza from coal oven was more than great. Tasty even more than wood fired one."
• "The food was delicious, authentic, well priced."
• "The pizza was great."

Cons:

• "Pizza was burnt, cheese pizza tasted like tomatoes on burnt pita."
• "Pizza was dry, the price of extra meat was too high, cheesecake was old and smelly."
• "The Caprese salad was alright, the eggplant parm was very dry, possibly overfried and the sauce was very bland and sweet."
• "All I could taste was bland cream with soggy pasta."
• "Our pizza seemed undercooked, floppy, and full of raw garlic."
• "The cheese ravioli with pistachio sauce lacked depth and was tougher than it should have been."
• "The pizza lacks flavor, and the cheese was tough and rubbery."

Price & Value

Pros:

• "Prices are reasonable for NYC."
• "The pizza was very reasonably priced, though."
• "Prices for NYC were fantastic!"
• "You can't beat the price for such delicious pizza."
• "Food was Excellent, servings were huge, prices for NYC were fantastic!"
• "Price was also fair especially considering you are in the heart of midtown."
• "Fairly priced for the area."

Cons:

• "$26 personal pepperoni pizza, $28 ravioli and $5 soft drinks with no free refills."
• "The pizza was average in quality and taste, but pricier than other places."
• "Tourist trap, the food is not worth the cost."
• "Little bit more expensive than eating a slice off the street."
• "The bill was outrageously expensive."
• "It is overpriced."
• "A little pricey."