99 Cent Fresh Pizza Reviews Summary

Category: Pizza restaurant New York

Address: 143 W 40th St, New York, NY 10018, USA

Phone: +12123665550

Rating: 4.5
based on 169 reviews.

Price and Value

Pros:

  • "Some of the best dollar pizza you can get in the city."
  • "2 slices and a drink for $2.75 is amazing."
  • "Cash only, but $1 a slice is perfect."
  • "For the price, you can't expect gourmet, but if you're looking for affordable, good pizza to satisfy your hunger, give this place a try."
  • "Also, four slices of pizza and two sodas ended up coming up to a total of $6.50 which was great!"
  • "Dollar for a well made pizza slice especially in the heart of Manhattan close by Times Square and Penn station. Every penny worth it!!"
  • "The $2.75 deal for two slices and a can of pop is great value!"

Cons:

  • "Pizza is bad above that staff is least concerned about the homeless people sitting inside and staring at your pizza."
  • "The pizza was completely burnt."
  • "We ordered 2 slices of pizza and 2 pops and they charged me $20!!! My friends and I felt intimidated to pay or else these thugs would cause us harm."
  • "Count your change when going to this place. They're ripping off people by not giving all their change back."
  • "We ordered 3 pizzas and a soda in the middle of the day, we should pay 3,75$ dollars but owner told me that it’s 5,5$ with tax. I guess he understood that we are tourists and ripped us off."
  • "Got two 'meat lover' slices and was quoted $10. If the cheese slice is $1, how is this $5?"
  • "The cashier charged me a $1.25 extra until I had received my order."

Service and Staff

Pros:

  • "Such great service as well."
  • "The staff treats you like family and are very respectful."
  • "The staff are always super quick even when its crowded."
  • "The person working was very nice, the pizza was very fresh."
  • "The service was polite and quick."
  • "Friendly staff and tasty pizza."
  • "The service was quick, the staff were friendly and the pizza tasted amazing."

Cons:

  • "Staff aren’t helpful that’s probably because they have always people to attend and at the same time cooking pizzas."
  • "The man has a nasty attitude won't ever ever buy from there again."
  • "Still ended up waiting about 15 minutes just to get our order taken."
  • "Not sure why it was so hard to understand our order, but all 3 guys working there kept messing it up."
  • "Now the staff has changed and they are too busy arguing amongst themselves to take an order."
  • "Staff is very rude."
  • "I rarely leave reviews, but the behaviour of the staff was disturbingly unprofessional."

Quality and Taste

Pros:

  • "The DELICIOUS and GREAT QUALITY pizza here!!!"
  • "It's very fresh and the original test of hot freshly baked cheese pizza."
  • "It’s cheap pizza and honestly it’s good, got a cheese and a slice with pepperoni and sausage."
  • "The pizza comes out fast and hot."
  • "Great pizza for the price! Love putting garlic powder and chili flakes on it."
  • "The pizza slices were the best by far of many we tried during our trip to NYC."
  • "The pizza was hot, fresh, and delicious."

Cons:

  • "The place really is kinda low class but the pizza honestly isn’t bad at all!"
  • "This place was pretty hectic, not super clean compared to the other 30 pizza places I've gone to in the city. Was definitely the worst tasting pizza I had while visiting."
  • "The mushrooms were clearly canned and did not look appetizing."
  • "The pizza was way too soft it was basically eating bread with sauce and cheese."
  • "The pizza is a lot softer with no crunch compared to Joe's and had virtually no sauce, so just basically cheesy bread."
  • "Would not recommend this place for the pizza or the service."
  • "Pizza is okay nothing exceptional."

Ambiance and Cleanliness

Pros:

  • "There's a nice seating area across the street."
  • "There are some nice shaded benches across the street where we sat down to eat our pizza."
  • "There is a great seating area across the street."

Cons:

  • "The eating counters could be a little more cleaner."
  • "No space to sit inside. Limited service. Limited options. Limited cleanliness."
  • "Again there is not much room so there is no indoor seating."
  • "The place looks dirty and not much clean."
  • "FYI the pizza was cold and there was rats everywhere outside and in the bathroom area."
  • "Place it’s kind of dirty."
  • "The venue is as expected - small and not the cleanest."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.