"The staff was very friendly and our slices were nice and crisp."
"The service is prompt and friendly."
"Really quick service and cute interior decor."
"The service was speedy and efficient, the interior was a testament to simplicity."
"The staff was nice, the store is in a convenient location, and we got served quickly."
"Service is always great, the guys there are always super nice, especially Delfino."
Cons:
"Waited 20 minutes in line just for them to tell me they only had mushroom pizza left when they didn’t even close for another 2 hours and refused to make another kind for anyone."
"Then… he said we’re closed at 10 when google says they close at 11."
"Deducting one star because guy didn’t wear a mask 😷."
"The guy with the goatee is the worst moron I have ever talked to...he doesn't know Communication at all."
"Very rude! Requested to wait for fresh slices... the attitude was unnecessary."
"And the Mexican of the register have actitud, I mean I paid 6$ for a piece YOU CAN GIVE ME A PARMESAN DONT EAT THERE PLEASE IF YOU RESPECT YOUR STOMACH!!!"
"The pizza was very good. However, the guy serving us was a real jerk."
Pizza Quality
Pros:
"New favorite slice in the city."
"Perfect thin crust with enough substance to fold, tangy sauce and several different cheeses that make each bite different."
"The pizza was very good."
"The pepperoni is definitely legit."
"Chewy light airy dough that finishes with a superior crunch on the bottom."
"The pep slices are just the right size, there's a lot of them per slice and they are cooked to perfection."
"Best pizza we had in NYC and tried quite a few of them! Every ingredient from the cheese sauce and toppings are top notch and I believe freshly sourced from Italy."
Cons:
"$5 for a pizza that I thought was going to be delicious when in fact it tasted horrible."
"Nothing special."
"Then I tried the Upside Pizza!! It tasted like a salt mine with a hint of pepperoni. Pretty bad."
"The thin crust pizza is pretty good, but nothing to write home about. The Upside thick crust pan style pizza on the other hand is absolutely INCREDIBLE and unlike anything else I’ve had."
"The pizza is still soo good but the crust is SO bad! Not only is it too big but it's like a cracker and for someone like myself who eats the WHOLE slice, it was not edible."
"The slices barely had any flavor and the cheese (which at first appears to be mozzarella mixed with ricotta) had no flavor at all."
"So BAD the flavor and the pieces so salty, burned, and dry!!!"
Value and Pricing
Pros:
"At $4 a slice, it isn't the cheapest, but it doesn't really break the bank, and I'm a small human, so a slice is good enough for me!"
"Price - great."
"A pepperoni slice and soda cost $7 and was well worth it."
"Priced about a buck or two more than average slice but well worth it for such a quality pizza."
Cons:
"For $5 a slice it's way too pricy."
"Charged me $35 for a pepperoni pizza."
"Your Pizza is good but cmon. $43 dollars for a pie."
"I am ordering 6 pies and your price is almost 400 dollars with all your fees."
"Average NYC pizza at best and $6 for a square slice of pepperoni is just not worth it."
Atmosphere and Decor
Pros:
"An unassuming looking pizzeria on a busy corner serves surprising pizza menu such as 'white pizza with mushrooms and lemon'."
"The cups and general design are very '90s."
"Decor: Hello Crocket and Tubbs!"
"In the name of all things pink, the decor is bright and sunny showing a great deal of care in imagery."
"A quick walk from Port Authority will bring you to this standing room only pizzeria with saved by the bell decor."
Cons:
"Standing room only but worth it."
"Be aware there is also no room inside to eat either (not even standing tables inside)."
"Purely a takeout spot, only a couple of standing tables to eat your slices."
"If you want to sit and dine this isn't the place for you."
"The only shortcoming is the seating, very limited and standing tables only."
Customer Experience
Pros:
"Beautiful area and the workers very welcoming to me and my friends."
"The hip, music lends a vibe you immediately notice on this busy corner pizzaria."
"Simple spot to grab a slice. The guys working were efficient and friendly."
"Fast service and pleasant workers."
"We have thoroughly enjoyed pizza and garlic knots two days in a row. It's take out only. So, don't expect to sit down there. We enjoyed ours back at the hotel. Delicious food. Friendly, efficient staff."
Cons:
"Awful experience, ruined our Sunday Family dinner."
"Then… he said we’re closed at 10 when google says they close at 11."
"Called to question about ordering a pick up order and when I said I wanted slices of pizza, the man said no we have people ordering pies over the phone and hung up on me."
"This restaurant was prejudiced against me. They declined me service."
"Placed an order via Slice. Two hours later and no pizza."
"But the service was not the best. I saw a worker drop a pizza slice and they didn't quite get my order right."
"It's expensive for what you get. 2 Bros pizza down the street is way better."