Sweet Waters Steakhouse Reviews Summary

Category: Steak house

Address: 43 Elm St, Westfield, NJ 07090, USA

Phone: +19083172599

Rating: 4.6
based on 149 reviews.

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "Great atmosphere, nice attentive staff."
  • "Sweet Waters Steakhouse is a small restaurant with a wonderful atmosphere."
  • "SWSH's atmosphere is wonderful... cozy and nice background music at an enjoyable volume."
  • "Atmosphere was intimately traditional with a decent bar area."
  • "This place has such a romantic atmosphere yet also kids friendly."
  • "Great atmosphere. You can enjoy laughs with friends or private conversations with your date."
  • "Fabulous meal, attentive service and great ambiance."

Cons:

  • "The only negative was the bar directly at the entrance blocking flow of traffic."
  • "It's like every snob in this township decided to drop by here."
  • "However they sat us in a area where a family was having a birthday dinner and they were very loud."
  • "The atmosphere is filled with a bunch of white people so understandably all eyes get drawn to you."
  • "Not sure what I would consider the atmosphere in there."
  • "The lighting during the day could be better to give it that extra oomf."
  • "It was a Small table (for 1) in the corner where my son couldn't sit comfortably."

Service

Pros:

  • "Very friendly and attentive, my cup always runneth over in the best way."
  • "Service is good and responsive."
  • "The service was great."
  • "Our waiter Jamie was helpful with suggestions and full of energy & enthusiasm."
  • "The service was excellent, warm and inviting."
  • "Service was wonderful! The food was great! Our server was William - great guy and provided top notch service!"
  • "The service was outstanding."

Cons:

  • "Service could have been a lot better."
  • "Horrible hostess."
  • "They were not careful with our request to not cross contaminate our daughter's meal due to her food allergy."
  • "We did not have reservations... They turned us away flat."
  • "I believe they were dismissive towards us."
  • "Service very slow."
  • "Our waiter barely recognized us, got our order wrong and never came to see if everything was OK so it wasn't rectified."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food was amazing and cooked to perfection."
  • "Food was awesome as usual!"
  • "The food was delicious and very fresh."
  • "The steak sandwich however was delicious."
  • "The food was delicious and seasoned just right."
  • "The food was absolutely amazing!! Even the dinner rolls were awesome!!"
  • "The food was the best we have had in a long time."

Cons:

  • "Don't get the ribeye! I've had it 3x and it's not the best cut."
  • "The Mac n cheese was okay. For me it was a bit too oily and the top was a bit too chewy."
  • "The lamb chops I ordered medium they were well-done no flavor."
  • "The oysters was not fresh, the filet mignon was not seasoned and the drinks were watered down."
  • "The Chilean Seabass was dry no flavor on a bed of beans."
  • "My burger was so salty I couldn't finish it."
  • "The tuna tartare was not good."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.