"Went in with a large group at an off hour and got good food and friendly, attentive service."
"Phil the bartender is phenomenal, he is such a hard worker and it shows."
"Jess was super friendly behind the bar and made it a very pleasant experience!"
"Amazing service by Amanda, very attentive and friendly."
"The staff were very friendly."
"Our server Allie was very friendly and helpful."
Cons:
"Service was poor...maybe because we weren't regulars."
"They held us against our will after disrespecting my girlfriend."
"Service needs to be better!!! Went in with a party for lunch it was a total disaster!!!"
"Disappointed. Understand busy night but one server in especially today did not provide a good service."
"People were actually told they could not be served due to lack of staff."
"Service not so much. Mixed drink was horrible and waitress did not check on us or refill our drinks until we were ready to leave."
"Waitress spent too much time talking to the men and flirting instead of waiting on an old lady wasting my time."
Food Quality
Pros:
"Food was good."
"Their apple walnut salad is pretty darn delicious."
"The open faced Reuben sandwich was outstanding."
"The fish was flaky and lightly battered."
"Food was very good as well as crab soup."
"The food is absolutely delicious, they have a great variety."
"The ribeye special tonight was out of this world."
Cons:
"The food came out lukewarm/cold."
"Our food took over an hour to arrive and everyone's food was cold."
"The crab cake was frozen... the fries, no excuse for old oil, no excuse for the filthy table, no excuse for the cole slaw which was so close to compost."
"The food came out ice cold!"
"However the Cream of Crab Soup seemed verrrry watered down and flavorless."
"I tried their veggie burger without cheese; it was a mushroom with two tiny slivers of roasted peppers."
"Worst food and service ever. Took so long for everything and it was all cold."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"Friday night Bartender was pleasant and spot on with a nice crowd and nice vibe."
"The best bar in South Jersey. Live music on many nights, local musicians who are very talented."
"The Old Oar House is by far the best go to Bar in Downtown Millville."
"Wonderful South Jersey gem! Diverse and accepting crowd."
"Comfortable Irish pub atmosphere and friendly staff."
"There's a nice, relaxed atmosphere."
"This bar has a great atmosphere, lunch specials every day, impressive dinner specials that change once a week."
Cons:
"The indoor bar is a little tight, and it's extremely hard to hear anything when they have a live performance there."
"Loud obnoxious drunk people on a Sunday afternoon."
"The restaurant outside is so dark and lacks curb appeal, no front entrance."
"After working our way through the crowd of drunken senior citizens dancers we found a table in the non bar side."
"And the roaches...a whole other story."
"Place is dirty, bathroom was icky and sticky/outdated."
"The young girls who work there are constantly poked and prodded by the older predatory men who are running the establishment."
Price and Value
Pros:
"Great prices!"
"Incredible food, generous serving sizes, great prices!"
"Love the multitude of beer and the food delicious, prices are fair for fare, wait staff friendly n efficient."
Cons:
"The only thing I can say about this place is the ridiculous prices of food and the beer."
"Lunch for two of us was $72.00... Expensive for lunch."
"Now I see why their specials and beer menu have no prices so make sure you ask before you order."
"NEVER get the nachos ... 2 hand fulls of chips, melted cheese wiz, a bit of crushed jalapeños and a few leaves of lettuce ... and had the balls to charge $10.00."
"You must be a very cautious consumer and ask for prices in advance or you will be slapped with additional upcharges unknowingly."
"Waitress was deceiving and didn’t tell us the whole STORY and when the bill arrived; PRICES were higher than the menu stated."
"He obviously has no interest in making sure that patrons are receiving honest food at honest prices."
Management and Staff Conduct
Pros:
"The bartenders are eager to make every single person that comes in smile, and really engage in conversations."
"The bartenders are great and the drinks and food are always good quality."
"The best bar in town, I highly recommend sandy, Tiffany, Debbie, heather,Joe, and herb for a good night!"