"The perfect slice! The crust is thin and crunchy and you can easily pick it up to bite into it."
"But what truly elevates their slices is the impeccable crunch, delivering that satisfying texture that's synonymous with the New York experience."
"This has to be one of the better pizzas 🍕 I have ever had, from the crust to the sauce to the cheeses, this pizza has robust flavor."
"The crust is perfect and the toppings are fresh and flavorful."
"The crust was amazingly crispy."
"Crust was thin and had a perfect amount of crunch."
"The crust is just perfectly crispy yet soft on the inside."
Cons:
"The crust is especially inconsistent and was burnt closer to the texture of a dry cracker in my recent visit."
"I think I got unlucky and my crust was crispier than most pictures here."
"Both pizza slices I ordered came out incredibly dry, might I say desiccated!"
"Crust of pizza is somewhat chewy and not crispy."
"The crust however was a little too hard (the roof of my mouth was scratched up after)."
"Personally, the crust is too glutinous and it was kind of a hassle to chew through an entire slice."
"The pizza was not crispy."
Service & Atmosphere
Pros:
"The line was long but it moved quick. Once you order you have to wait outside in the cold."
"They even offer to cut slices in half if you would like to share!"
"The people working there were very upbeat and pleasant."
"And the employees were very friendly and full of energy even though there were a bunch of customers."
"The staff were vibrant and kind."
"The staff are very friendly and run the queue well."
"The staff were incredibly welcoming and efficient, making my visit a delightful experience."
Cons:
"Service was too slow to compensate and made it all too crowded."
"Waiting 45 min on line, then another 15 min after I ordered to get my pizza on a Sat afternoon :((("
"Despite the long lines, it took us about an hour to just get a simple slice."
"Lower stars on atmosphere because they dont have much seating so we ate standing up on the sidewalk."
"Staff rushes you along and gets annoyed with you."
"Seating is difficult since there's people who are currently eating pizza, people that finished a while ago, and the worst offenders, people 'saving' a table for their friends who are waiting in line."
"I only took a star off for atmosphere because the neighborhood is sketch and lots of people across the street were doing drugs and snorting cocaine."
Price & Value
Pros:
"Their whole pizzas get pretty pricey, but still worth."
"I am not going to lie it is expensive but it is worth the splurge."
"Slices are a little more expensive than I’m used to but it’s reflected in the quality of the pizza."
"Prices aren’t unreasonable as the pizza is super high quality!"
"And on top of that, such an affordable price for a quality slice."
"Great price point for this high quality pizza!"
"An average slice is around $5 but they can to up to $7."
Cons:
"Pies recommended as slice set you back $13 per pop."
"I mean it’s delicious but not so much different than Joe’s pizza which is both cheaper and doesn’t have queues on their Williamsburg branch anyways."
"But $24 for 3 slices is kinda sticky."
"The pizza is not exactly cheap (5.50 for a slice of their signature burrata pizza, and 6 for their fig jam and bacon)."
"A bit expensive, but I think that's fair for using high quality ingredients."
"They charge you $1 extra if you need to box a pie you ordered to go."
"I have only one critique and that was the cost of anchovy slice. The margherita was $3.50 and the anchovy was $6 - a pepperoni is $4.50 for reference."
Food Quality
Pros:
"The pizza was everything that you could ask for in a NY slice. Tasty, crisp, and mesmerizing."
"Fresh ingredients make for a quintessential New York slice that’s not too greasy, thin, crispy, and delicious."
"Absolutely amazing slice, the best I had during my visit."
"This may be the best slice I have had. It was crispy and had a good pull. Very good texture."
"The cheese and basil toppings are sheer perfection, creating a harmonious balance of flavors."
"The pizza itself tasted amazing. Great flavours and texture and doesn’t feel too heavy either."
"The crust is light and crispy, the undercarriage is cooked well and the topping was yum."
Cons:
"Pretty good pizza, but the quality is inconsistent and the wait is long."
"Decent pizza establishment... Delicious, but not worth going out of your way for in my opinion."
"The pizza was no better than chain delivery and twice if not triple the price."
"The white slice was a little bland."
"The pizza itself was exceptional, boasting a perfectly crispy crust and high-quality ingredients."
"Good pizza, but nothing phenomenal."
"Used to be way better from when they first opened up until recently to whenever they changed their recipe."