"Hands down, best cheeseburger I have ever had! The Emmy Burger does not disappoint."
"Best burger I’ve had from a restaurant. Hands down."
"Easily the best burger I’ve ever had!"
"The burger truly was one of the best I’ve ever had. Super juicy and tender, you barely even need to chew!"
"The burger is as good as advertised (it's ranked on several lists as one of the best in New York City)!!"
"Genuinely the best burger I have eaten in my entire life every element of it was amazing and the experience was just as good."
Cons:
"Everything about this spot was great, but when it came to the famous burger, it was just way too salty."
"The burger is definitely not the best of New York, is too greasy and taste wise is not that truly impressive of what the price suggest."
"For 31 dollars a burger it’s a waste of money, cold and tasteless."
"The burger was overrated and too rich."
"The burger tastes okay but nothing out of the ordinary."
"I must say the food let me down. Def not the best burger in nyc."
"The Emmy Burger is a super pretentious overpriced mediocre cheeseburger."
Pizza
Pros:
"The best specialty pizza in NYC. Euro-Argentine-inspired with fresh ingredients with special fusions from honey to truffle."
"The Chicken Karaage was excellent and so was the pizza."
"Pizza was fantastic, service was great. I would come back here in a heartbeat."
"The Williams I ordered from this Emily's was an effing Spiritual Experience for me and maybe the best Pizza I've ever had in my life."
"Wood fired pizza that soars to heights of deliciousness matched with fun creative pizza topping combinations you won't find elsewhere."
"The colony pizza really surprised me with its honey touch."
"the famous original dan’s pink pizza was the best pizza i’ve ever had in my life."
Cons:
"I didn't like the vodka pizza it tasted like the plain pizza honestly."
"The pie itself overcooked around the edges, and I'm not a fan of burnt crust."
"The pizza here is mediocre and you would be better off going to an old & authentic Italian pizzeria place in Brooklyn."
"Pizza is okay, nothing special."
"The pizza was the greatest disappointment of the night, the ratio of sauce and cheese and dough were so off."
"The classic pizza it was below average. EmmyBurger i have tried better than this one."
"Pizza was super average. Crust was soggy. Flavor was decent."
Service
Pros:
"The service was excellent."
"Staff was kind, great location and great menu options."
"The server was very nice and attentive."
"The service was fast, the staff were kind."
"Great service every time we come too from all employees."
"First let me start by saying service is excellent."
"The service was excellent in spite of the place being packed on an early Sunday evening."
Cons:
"Service was rushed. I understand they're busy, but when we were served pizza we didn't have any plates, and we had to help ourselves from the table next to us."
"The restaurant is crowded and noisy- makes it hard to carry on a conversation."
"Service sucked and food was nothing special."
"Service was slow and take a very long time to help."
"Service was NOT friendly and they were happy to rush us out."