Emily Reviews Summary

Category: Pizza restaurant Brooklyn, New York

Address: 919 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11238, USA

Phone: +13478449588

Rating: 4.4
based on 267 reviews.

Burgers

Pros:

  • "THIS WAS THE BEST BURGER I EVER ATE. amazing!!"
  • "Hands down, best cheeseburger I have ever had! The Emmy Burger does not disappoint."
  • "Best burger I’ve had from a restaurant. Hands down."
  • "Easily the best burger I’ve ever had!"
  • "The burger truly was one of the best I’ve ever had. Super juicy and tender, you barely even need to chew!"
  • "The burger is as good as advertised (it's ranked on several lists as one of the best in New York City)!!"
  • "Genuinely the best burger I have eaten in my entire life every element of it was amazing and the experience was just as good."

Cons:

  • "Everything about this spot was great, but when it came to the famous burger, it was just way too salty."
  • "The burger is definitely not the best of New York, is too greasy and taste wise is not that truly impressive of what the price suggest."
  • "For 31 dollars a burger it’s a waste of money, cold and tasteless."
  • "The burger was overrated and too rich."
  • "The burger tastes okay but nothing out of the ordinary."
  • "I must say the food let me down. Def not the best burger in nyc."
  • "The Emmy Burger is a super pretentious overpriced mediocre cheeseburger."

Pizza

Pros:

  • "The best specialty pizza in NYC. Euro-Argentine-inspired with fresh ingredients with special fusions from honey to truffle."
  • "The Chicken Karaage was excellent and so was the pizza."
  • "Pizza was fantastic, service was great. I would come back here in a heartbeat."
  • "The Williams I ordered from this Emily's was an effing Spiritual Experience for me and maybe the best Pizza I've ever had in my life."
  • "Wood fired pizza that soars to heights of deliciousness matched with fun creative pizza topping combinations you won't find elsewhere."
  • "The colony pizza really surprised me with its honey touch."
  • "the famous original dan’s pink pizza was the best pizza i’ve ever had in my life."

Cons:

  • "I didn't like the vodka pizza it tasted like the plain pizza honestly."
  • "The pie itself overcooked around the edges, and I'm not a fan of burnt crust."
  • "The pizza here is mediocre and you would be better off going to an old & authentic Italian pizzeria place in Brooklyn."
  • "Pizza is okay, nothing special."
  • "The pizza was the greatest disappointment of the night, the ratio of sauce and cheese and dough were so off."
  • "The classic pizza it was below average. EmmyBurger i have tried better than this one."
  • "Pizza was super average. Crust was soggy. Flavor was decent."

Service

Pros:

  • "The service was excellent."
  • "Staff was kind, great location and great menu options."
  • "The server was very nice and attentive."
  • "The service was fast, the staff were kind."
  • "Great service every time we come too from all employees."
  • "First let me start by saying service is excellent."
  • "The service was excellent in spite of the place being packed on an early Sunday evening."

Cons:

  • "Service was rushed. I understand they're busy, but when we were served pizza we didn't have any plates, and we had to help ourselves from the table next to us."
  • "The restaurant is crowded and noisy- makes it hard to carry on a conversation."
  • "Service sucked and food was nothing special."
  • "Service was slow and take a very long time to help."
  • "Service was NOT friendly and they were happy to rush us out."
  • "the service was non existent."
  • "Waitress was rude and service is slow."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.