Emmy Squared Pizza: East Village, New York Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The pizza with vodka sauce was AMAZING!"
• "The good polly pizza was fantastic and the breadsticks were to die for."
• "The MVP pizza a perfect 10."
• "The pizza was saur good! I got the vodka pizza and it was so delicious."
• "The Brussel sprout Salad Was AMAZING."
• "Really good Detroit style deep dish pizza!"
• "The pizza is fantastic! I normally prefer very thin crust pizza, but these have a delicious thicker crust and every piece has a crispy edge."

Cons:

• "The pizza was very salty- hard to eat and enjoy."
• "Mozzarella sticks completely lackluster and not worth it and should be taken off the menu."
• "And, the pizza was just like Pizza Hut. Yuck!"
• "Our pizzas were not good. The dough was not fully risen and it was gritty."
• "The Nashville hot chicken pizza was a total miss."
• "The pizza seemed much more stingy in terms of toppings for the price."
• "The salad was absolute trash."

Service

Pros:

• "Also the service is very friendly!"
• "The staff are super sweet, the bartender came over and chatted with us and the service was quick!"
• "Normally staff is very friendly and accommodating, especially in off hours."
• "The wait staff and manager Erik G are friendly and helpful."
• "The best part of our night was the superb service we received from CHYNA!"
• "Our server, Justin, was also super kind and very attentive."
• "Our server, Bryan though was the best part. He had great recommendations for cocktails and food, checked on us frequently and overall was just delightful."

Cons:

• "They closed over an hour early... the host's response was aggressive essentially a 'not my problem' response."
• "The bar dinner service was below average as the bartender was not attentive nor friendly."
• "We had a larger party, and it took almost 20 min. To get a server to come over and take our drink order."
• "Waited close to 2 hours for delivery and then was missing most of the order - completely incorrect."
• "The service was very disappointing."
• "The waitress apologized but otherwise rarely came by our table."
• "I have never had such bad service and such carelessness with an allergy."

Value

Pros:

• "Pricing is really fair: our dinner costed around $45 with two beers."
• "Pricing is not extortionate for the quality and value you get."
• "Outstanding selection of delicious, fresh personal sized pizzas dressed with a slew of tasty toppings atop a medium thick crispy crust."

Cons:

• "$23 seems overpriced for the small pie that you get."
• "It's $$$. A pizza and salad somehow came out to $50 after tip."
• "In what planet are you guys charging so much for so little food."
• "The burger was definitely overcooked and not worth the $26."
• "Is it worth $26? Absolutely not."

Ambiance

Pros:

• "The atmosphere is relaxed and fun, and the food delicious."
• "Laid back ambiance."
• "The atmosphere is warm and inviting."
• "I absolutely love the vibe in there."
• "It’s a great location to reserve for group events with friends. It has an awesome vibe."
• "Seriously a great ambiance, perfect for 1st dates or friends reunion."
• "The vibe was great. Just seemed like a place where everyone was having fun."

Cons:

• "Vibes and service are pretty lacking compared to the three prior iterations."
• "The front of house looked like a cheap pizza takeout joint."
• "Is this pizza restaurant or a bar, a takeaway or somewhere for a quick slice and a beer? I'm confused."
• "It was too dark to see, and eating is evidently more visual than I realized."