Holy Tomato Reviews Summary

Atmosphere & Decor

Pros:

• "What a fun and funky place!"
• "This place is very unique and home-feeling."
• "What I found most enjoyable is the decor."
• "The atmosphere is eclectic and comforting."
• "Cute decor and lovely ambience."
• "This is a small, funky restaurant filled with eclectic decor, fun atmosphere."
• "It’s eclectic, welcoming, and most importantly DELISH!"

Cons:

• "It's loud and very heavy bass. It's a restaurant damn it, not a dance club."
• "We couldn't eat in since it was a small place and really hot in there."
• "The only thing that I didn't like is that it is very small inside, and parking is an issue when it's busy as there is no parking lot."

Service

Pros:

• "The staff all seem super upbeat and happy."
• "Our waitress was... so FRIENDLY, Upbeat, down to earth."
• "Staff were very friendly and helpful explaining the menu and their current specials."
• "The staff was quick, friendly, and helpful."
• "The staff has to be some of the nicest people I have ever met."
• "Staff is extremely friendly and helpful!"
• "Fabulous and friendly service."

Cons:

• "Also, ordering pizza to go no matter how busy it might be inside the restaurant shouldn't take 1.5 hours."
• "Was refused service even though the restaurant closes at 9 PM."
• "Was not even offered take out and was rudely told they are not serving anyone over a hour before closing."
• "We love the pizza and salad here, however we tried to place a takeout order at 730. They told me they were done for the night."
• "Then I notice the people that came in after us got their food first and were finished paid and left, while we were still sitting there waiting for someone to come over to pack up our food."
• "No customer should be spoken to with such abrasion, even if you’re having a bad night with staff."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "House salad is out of this world."
• "Best thin crust pizza in South Jersey!"
• "One of best, if not, THE best pizzas I’ve ever had."
• "Their house salad is flat out incredible."
• "Every pizza on their menu is delicious, their toppings are top tier."
• "The food is INCREDIBLE! From the salads to the pizza, everything is so so delicious."
• "The pizza is the best we have ever had with fresh minced garlic each day and hand crushed tomato sauce."

Cons:

• "The chicken Alfredo and the honey Buffalo on the other hand, were not appealing."
• "There was wayyy too much garlic that was grossly undercooked."
• "The pizza was Stone Cold! ... it's not my thing. ... zero flavor."
• "Hate to give a good spot bad reviews but this pizza was just not good. It was cold to start de.f don't recommend pickup."
• "The middle of the pizza was practically raw."
• "Probably the worst slice I've ever had in my life and I spent $17 on a large pizza which is the most expensive piece of have ever bought."
• "Complete and utter disappointment. I fed half the pizza TO MY ROOMATES DOG."

Value

Pros:

• "A group of my family and friends like to go during the pizza and salad special, which is basically salad and pizza for two people for about ~$20."
• "$19 for a large one topping Pizza."
• "The Tuesday special can't be beat: 2 salads, 2 drinks, and an original pie for $23."
• "Our bill was under 40 bucks, too."
• "Prices are in line with other places."
• "Great flavor awesome Crispy crust at a really affordable price."

Cons:

• "One pizza and salad for two was $45.00!"