"The crust is perfect, everything is perfect here!"
"The sauce and cheese is also very good."
"All their pizzas are great, but the margherita one is just perfect, crunchy, right crust, right amount flavour!"
"Every bite of my ricotta cheese pizza was damn near gave me cold chills like the warm of my soul."
"The pizza tastes so delicious! Just having their original pizza slice was cheesy and just enough sauce."
"The slices are good, and the sauce not overly sweet."
"Their sauce is perfection. It’s so flavorful, we just love it. The dough is the right consistency and tastes fresh."
Cons:
"If this place has a rating of almost five stars then New York really does not no what good pizza is it was one of the worst slice I ever had."
"Garlic knots had way too much parsley. Couldn't even taste the bread. Tasted like eating a plant."
"The Instagram famous garlic bread is nothing but soggy bread dipped in cheese and more oil."
"The pizza was absolutely terrible. The restaurant sold me what seemed like a 1+ day old pizza with added cheese and pepperoni."
"The sicilian slice I had was burned and barely edible."
"You could not really eat the crust or near the crust because the crust was hard & burnt and near the crust the pizza was hard and dry."
"Pizza was old, so by default 2 bros >>>"
Service
Pros:
"Great people that work there, great service great food."
"Super friendly staff and the owner is awesome."
"The service is friendly, they're fast and the pizza is really tasty."
"Employees are always super nice, delivery guy is very friendly, and they always add the red pepper and parm when I request."
"The staff is very fast and friendly."
"Consistently delicious, great customer service."
"The employees were very kind as well."
Cons:
"Customer service isn’t any better either and interior is straight up dirty as well."
"Long story short, there are plenty of places in the east village with good pizza and better customer service."
"Guys at the cash register will also try to quickly skip thru the prices on the screen before customers have a chance to see how much they’re charged per item."
"This was a disaster of a dinner. Never again."
"I’m told they never made the pizza because the repeat order must have gotten lost."
"Don't get the cheesecake if you're getting delivery. It's not a real slice, but a tiny little pre-made cake about the size of a clementine. And for $8! Boo."
"Rude staff that'll look at you strange if you try to add seasoning."
Price
Pros:
"The prices were normal as well!"
"$12 for my whole meal. Not too bad."
"A side of Garlic Knots for $1.75 is a steal."
"Definitely one of my new late night pizza spots for sure, the prices were normal as well!"
Cons:
"$4 a slice is steep. And the extra 4% charge for using a credit card cuts even deeper."
"It's expensive at $3.25 a slice even though the slices are a good size."
"2 cheese slices came out to $13.50, before tip."
"$20.00 for a pepperoni pie is absolutely unacceptable being that it tastes horrible."
"They charge an extra $2.50 per slice for 'tax' and using a credit card."
"These are absurdly overpriced. $6 for a slice of pizza is pushing it."
"Additionally, overpriced one it costs 5.75."
Ambiance
Pros:
"This is a great place to drop in at anytime."
"Great spot on the corner of 9th and 1st Ave. They have a great selection of slices including margherita pizza (which was delicious) to Hawaiian slices and even jalapeño and pepperoni slices (they have a kick to them)."
"A slice jem in east village. Very famous and well known by the neighborhood."
"East Village Pizza is a must-visit spot!"
"The atmosphere is casual and cozy. Only about 10 seats for dining in."
"The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, and the staff is always welcoming."
"East Village Pizza is known as a late night neighborhood pizza place. small corner spot: couple of tables inside and a several outside."
Cons:
"No bathroom, so be aware of that."
"Very small, tight, cramped, not clean & NO RESTROOM."
"It’s small and intimate and not much to look at from outside."
"Limited seating. The place sits maybe 10 people inside. No outside seating."
"Small and cramped, same way it was before."
"Not sure why they have so many followers on Instagram, the pizza is average and there’s always a long wait late night when people are drinking."
"This place is horrible. Ordered on Ubereats and they made my bike rider wait 25 min after taking 25 min to prepare."