Camillo's Restaurant & Pizza Reviews Summary

Category: Pizza restaurant

Address: 31 MacArthur Ave, Sayreville, NJ 08872, USA

Phone: +17323904444

Rating: 4.5
based on 129 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Our server was very friendly and on top of everything and kept our drinks full the entire time."
  • "Our waitress was attentive and ask to fix our meals after we stated our disappointments."
  • "The service was great!"
  • "The staff took such good care of us, and even though is was a very very busy on Saturday night, Camillo came out to say hello and gave us a round of hugs."
  • "I just wanted to say how great the food was, and how attentive the staff were to our needs."
  • "Service wonderful and menu full of different meals."
  • "Service was very good and timely without being intrusive."

Cons:

  • "But I hate complaining so did not send back. I said something to waiter when bill the came. He said you should have said something in the beginning."
  • "Server not once asked If we wanted drink refills or if everything was ok."
  • "A server took away my friend's food before she was done."
  • "The server seemed disinterested in the issue."
  • "Unfortunately not going here anymore."
  • "Christmas Eve reservation - we still waited 2 hrs to be seated."
  • "Service…….a bit slow, but the staff is very nice."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Come here frequently and the food is great for a great price."
  • "Food is really πŸ‘Œ good."
  • "The food is OUTRAGEOUS, portions are huge, the sauces for the food are incredibly delicious."
  • "Crab ravioli and sea scallops.. In a white sambuca sauce with asparagus and sun-dried tomatoes absolutely mouth-wateringly delicious."
  • "The food is cooked perfectly and the flavor is phenomenal."
  • "The food, pizza, pasta dishes a couple with chicken, salmon, appetizers, steak sandwich, rice pudding and cheesecake were all delicious!"
  • "The food was great, they have large servings."

Cons:

  • "The food was bland no seasoning."
  • "If you're looking for authentic Italian food, this definitely is not the place to go."
  • "Please nobody come here me and my family came to eat some food and it was some of the most brutal and tasteless stuff I have ever had."
  • "Their veal marsala used to be an excellent dish but I was disappointed with the veal being on the chewy side and the sauce lacked flavor."
  • "The food was not seasoned and was overcooked."
  • "Food was just downright bad after two bites we were all complaining, stopped eating, 2 of us left with stomach aches."
  • "Sauces were watery even after letting sit the whole meal."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere alone is wonderful and warm, for Camillo’s just feels like home every time we’ve gone."
  • "It's a fair price point as well."
  • "The party room with 60 people was roomy and comfortable."
  • "There was a warm and inviting atmosphere especially with their beautiful Christmas decorations!"
  • "Seating is arranged just right and comfortable with dim lighting."
  • "Nice atmosphere! Very warm and welcoming."
  • "This is a great Italian restaurant that has a family vibe."

Cons:

  • "Do not recommend anymore."
  • "I'm changing my review from 5 stars to 3 based on the awful Margarita pizza I bought on Friday... it was 17.00 piece of garbage."
  • "Unfortunately the most tasteless Penne a la vodka I've ever had."
  • "The ambiance was lacking as it was very loud and could have benefitted with some piped in music."
  • "They wouldn't let us sit at certain tables adjacent to our own table even though the restaurant was empty."
  • "The Garlic Knots were dripping in oil and they weren't edible at all."
  • "Garlic knots are always stale."

Value

Pros:

  • "Good food and good value."
  • "Prices are Fair for the amount of Food you get."
  • "Prices are great as well."
  • "A wonderful variety and exceptionally fair prices."
  • "You will receive great servings of whatever you order."
  • "The prices are insanely low for the incredible amount of food that they give."
  • "A very reasonable bill!"

Cons:

  • "Food was good but not worth the wait."
  • "Need to be more ORGANIZED!!!! SPECIALLY ON THE Holladay,,,it was, horrible food Sat on counter if you didn't ask no one will let you know that your Order was ready."
  • "After that the pizza is horrible and dinners are small and the food is poor quality."
  • "Cost was very on par and no price gouging."
  • "I was told today to pay 'Extra' for the pepper & cheddar cheese on the side that's sprinkled on the Pizza."
  • "Stay away, save yourself the trouble and headache."
  • "The menu is extensive and prices are fair."

Accessibility

Pros:

  • "Good parking, Great service, and excellent food."
  • "Felt very safe as social distancing is being practiced."
  • "Ample space in the dining room for my wheelchair."
  • "I just wanted to say that it is COMPLETELY Handicap Accessible!"

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.