"The pizza is beautifully seared but still tender."
"The meatballs were so juicy and fluffy."
"Arturo's serves exceptional Neapolitan-style, wood-fired pizzas, with crisp crusts and perfect chewiness."
"The Margherita is excellent and the mozzarella is the real thing."
"Amazing coal oven pizza!"
"The dishes at Artie's were well-prepared and flavorful."
Cons:
"The pizza sauce has changed and the bread in the pizza is thicker."
"Margarita pizza was a little too burnt for my taste."
"The pizza with mushrooms needed more salt."
"The pizza is okay. The pizza has no flavor, crust is dry and need something to dip it In to get it down."
"Our pizza was very burnt & tasted like straight charcoal."
"I ordered a pepperoni pie with a cesar salad and I got home the pizza was DISGUSTING. Literally only 4 pieces of pepperoni on the pie, no cheese and the entire crust was burned black."
"One third of the pizza is crust that is burnt and I leave on the table for garbage."
Service
Pros:
"The service was top notch."
"The hostess and the servers were friendly and courteous considering they were quite busy."
"We had a great experience and will be back for more pizza excellence."
"The staff is very friendly and helpful."
"Service was top notch from the hostess to all of our servers…attentive, welcoming & accommodating."
"The staff is very friendly and attentive."
"The staff here are super nice, we love them all."
Cons:
"They weren’t accommodating any takeout orders because the dining room was too busy."
"They wouldn’t pick up the phone - it was a busy Saturday night."
"Hostess had us wait 45 min and then didn’t honor our reservation."
"Food is good but service is horrendous."
"Simple requests took an uncomfortably long time to fulfill, and their lack of apology or concern only added to the frustration."
"The staff members seemed disinterested, inattentive and displayed a lack of basic courtesy."
"The service at Artie's was nothing short of a disaster."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting."
"Inside, the space is nice and modern."
"Arties is very spacious and inviting."
"The atmosphere felt like home n the food n the service was extremely far n beyond my expectations."
"The new Artie's is a great space. Nice and open, modern, and fresh."
"The atmosphere was amazing with great, attentive service."
"Good service and a modern, loungy ambiance."
Cons:
"There's always, for the most part, at least a 30 min way."
"I’m pretty floored to come to the new location and find…longer waits, annoyed staff and a homogeneous and loft like cold atmosphere for dining."
"The new atmosphere is industrial like remnants of the Industrial Revolution; concrete, unfinished open ceilings. A large open space with little warmth."
"It can get a bit noisy."
"It was hard to carry on a conversation."
"The atmosphere is cafeteria - the tables and setup, the sounds, the service all work together to create a distinctive cafeteria vibe."
"The space is at least 10 times larger than the old location."
Value
Pros:
"Definitely worth the wait sometimes and don't give up on the Gavi wine or the arties lemonade and the white mushrooms pizza."
"It's worth the ride to get their pies and salad."
"The price is very reasonable."
"It's super affordable. We had a party of 8 and split 3 pizzas, 3 sides, and a few drinks from the cafe for $25 a person!"
"Arturo’s is a MUST STOP! Quality food at a very affordable price."
"From farm to table veggies and green dishes that are creative and tasty, to home-made Pizza's and pastas there is nothing you can go wrong with on the menu."
"The old arturos in a new location! Deff missing the old atmosphere and vibe, but all in all the food is still unbelievable."
Cons:
"A bit pricier than the original and wine options in pricing are not on par with pizza."
"Honestly it's not worth going here."
"Food is as good, and as expensive if not more so than it was at Arturo's."
"It's pricey and ridiculously overcrowded all the time."
"The Pizza was Excellent, but way over prices like most personal sized Pizza these days."
"Flavor and quality are still there, to a limited extent. It's hard to tell when Arturos has quartered the portion of ingredients but doubled the price."
"I ordered a pepperoni pie with a cesar salad and I got home the pizza was DISGUSTING. Literally only 4 pieces of pepperoni on the pie, no cheese and the entire crust was burned black."