Revello's Pizza Cafe Reviews Summary

Category: Pizza restaurant

Address: 502 S Main St, Old Forge, PA 18518, USA

Phone: +15704579843

Rating: 4.0
based on 139 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Good friendly service."
  • "Wonderful staff at Take-Out, easy exit."
  • "Peppy, friendly service."
  • "Jeanne was our server and worked hard to keep our service as fast as possible, among a light staff."
  • "April was working the tent outside on a rainy cold day (10/16) middle of the afternoon... she was just so energetic and genuinely happy."
  • "The server was very friendly and helpful."
  • "We appreciate the hospitality."

Cons:

  • "Waitress took our drink order and never came back with it until another waitress asked if our drink order was taken and we said yes 10 minutes ago."
  • "The staff took great pains not to acknowledge us until 30 minutes after our arrival."
  • "Horrendous service - waitress refused to make eye contact."
  • "Had zero customer service or proper understanding of the situation, when that’s all that had to happen."
  • "It was terrible, the service was so slow, it took 2 hours to make 2 slices of pizza and 4 pizza sticks, the waitress was incredibly rude, and the food was terrible!!!"
  • "Awful service and pizza. When arrived, we asked our order to be reviewed and it was wrong, they said they would remake it and they made it wrong AGAIN."
  • "Service was horrible. Hostess Diane makes eye contact with my fiance and I as we walk in. Never even addresses us."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "When it comes to finding the quintessential pizza experience, few places can match the authenticity and flavor that Revello's offers."
  • "I believe Revellos has the best white pizza in town."
  • "Old Forge Pizza done right in an iconic setting for this area."
  • "Delicious as always! Soft yet crispy, ordered extra cheese this time."
  • "The pizza was perfect. Crust was beyond great and it hit better than the others."
  • "The pizza was just as good as I remembered."
  • "Revello's pizza is what makes Old Forge the pizza capital of the world. The pizza is fabulous."

Cons:

  • "The white broccoli was totally disgusting, lacking filling & only half cooked at best!"
  • "The food was overcooked across the board."
  • "Tasted like card board!"
  • "The pizza tasted like school cafeteria pizza and came out cold."
  • "Pizza is like cafeteria pizza."
  • "The pizza that I got was really dry and cold."
  • "Normally when we come to eat at Revellos the pizza is really good, but today we came and it was a Friday during lent with many more customers and the pizza was burnt black."

Value

Pros:

  • "The pizza was very good, but a bit pricey."
  • "Overall, I would go again for pizza, especially if takeout, but nothing else. Also beer prices were reasonable for the area($4.50 for a Troegg's draft)."
  • "Very good, very reasonable price."
  • "Great crunchy crust and quality for your money."
  • "You definitely pay for the quality but the service is always friendly."

Cons:

  • "Don't waste your $$. Way overpriced and not the same quality."
  • "A little pricey having to pay extra per meatball on spaghetti, cheese on a burger and pretty much anything extra."
  • "It was 16 dollars for a frozen pizza; not cheap by any means."
  • "Who would pay $12 for one donut anyway? So disappointed. Definitely feel taken advantaged of."
  • "Scammed out of $66."
  • "One tray of red pizza and a hamburger and my bill came to 29.71."
  • "Came out to $38...Ok, I get the inflation part but the pizzas were premade/par-baked."

Ambience

Pros:

  • "I love the history and old photos on the wall of this place! And the pizza was absolutely fantastic, the epitome of Old Forge style pizza!"
  • "Nestled in a cozy corner of the city, this pizzeria has carved out a niche for itself."
  • "This place oozes of ambience that can only be found in an Italian restaurant."
  • "A splendid time is guaranteed for all."
  • "It's awesome to have a staff that actually enjoys what they do."
  • "Good vibes."
  • "Very nice place on Main Street Old Forge. Worth a visit !!!"

Cons:

  • "The place didn't look welcoming."
  • "Walked into a wall of screaming kids who were running around the restaurant and into the take-out area."
  • "Fruit flies everywhere."
  • "Could use some love on the outside, fresh paint and power wash would do the street some good."
  • "Went outside to see a band, no place to sit, all tables 'reserved' with no one at any of them until right before the band started."
  • "We walked into Revello's, and I personally made eye contact with not one, not two, but three servers, not one of which told us to seat ourselves, or wait to be seated."
  • "However the rudeness of the staff will keep me away from ever going there again."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.