Pizza One Reviews Summary

Category: Pizza restaurant

Address: 12 N Village Blvd, Sparta, NJ 07871, USA

Phone: +19738624933

Rating: 4.4
based on 190 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The Drunken Grandma Pie is the most popular speciality Pizza. From the first bite you can taste the quality of ingredients."
  • "The pasta was al dente and was complimented with a flavorful pink sauce with just the right amount of spice and plenty of shrimp."
  • "The food was incredibly fresh, bursting with flavor in every bite."
  • "The variety of flavours are amazing, and the pizza itself is just perfect."
  • "The mushroom pizza was fantastic."
  • "The star of the show, undoubtedly, is the chicken. Each sandwich is generously filled with succulent, tender chicken that is seasoned to perfection."
  • "Calamari were cooked to perfection; crispy, fresh and a generous portion."

Cons:

  • "The Yankee pastrami sandwich which was bland, but by no means terrible."
  • "The pizza is not good in my opinion, and the salads were outstanding, not any longer."
  • "The pizza wasn’t even fully cooked! The mushrooms were still raw, as were the pepperonis."
  • "The white pie was bland and the thin crust pie was soggy."
  • "Cold, soggy food isn’t worth the hour and a half wait after order time."
  • "The garlic knots tasted kinda funny."
  • "The worst part was the vegan pizza being 31 dollars altogether for a medium pie."

Service

Pros:

  • "Our server Vincent Anthony recommended the Lasagna, which was phenomenal."
  • "They also have fast delivery."
  • "It’s so beautiful inside and everyone was so kind and helpful."
  • "Staff were friendly and over atmosphere was good!"
  • "Staff was very accommodating and attentive."
  • "Our server was amazing."
  • "The staff were all very friendly, the restaurant was clean, and the place was busy."

Cons:

  • "He was rude, condescending, and overall had the worst attitude."
  • "Very disappointed in tonight's service the waiter was acting like it was a bother to serve us."
  • "Owner is very rude and so are some of the workers."
  • "Waiter and Manager were both very rude when we had to send back food."
  • "The waitress never asked us if we wanted dessert or coffee, she left the check while we were still finishing eating so we felt rushed."
  • "Service was slow. Was hoping to grab dinner b4 shopping and was there for about 1-1.5 hrs."
  • "The waitress has the audacity to complain about a 3 dollar tip."

Value

Pros:

  • "The prices are reasonable, considering the quality and quantity of the ingredients. You get excellent value for your money, which is a definite plus."
  • "Pricing is more than fair for expensive ingredients most often used."
  • "Great food. Free antipasta and bread during sit down service."
  • "Great service, cozy atmosphere, BYOB, and their cheese, bread & oil plate is EXCEPTIONAL!!!!"
  • "Excellent menu, classy atmosphere, friendly staff, and Covid Safe!!!!"
  • "Everything is always fresh, and the food never ceases to amaze me."
  • "Pizza One has great food at a great price, and a very friendly atmosphere."

Cons:

  • "Scammers. We placed a massive order and they charged us double for it."
  • "Very over priced for the food they serve."
  • "I paid over $20 for a buffalo pie that looked like a desolate warzone in a 10 man battle royale. NO sauce. At all."
  • "We waited 40 minutes for 3 appetizers to come out so we couldn’t even order a main meal."
  • "The delivery showed up at more than 20 minutes late and the food is lukewarm."
  • "Ordered well done calimari and it arrives barely cooked."
  • "The truffle fries were ice cold and had way too much Parmesan cheese on it."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "It’s so beautiful inside and everyone was so kind and helpful."
  • "The inside is beautiful too and the atmosphere feels cozy."
  • "The decor is upscale, with cozy booths, wall fireplaces and clean."
  • "Far from your average pizzeria. The inside looks like a chic, upscale NYC restaurant."
  • "The restaurant itself is absolutely gorgeous, and has a fireplace at every table!! Probably the nicest casual restaurant I’ve experienced!"
  • "The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, making it the ideal spot for a casual meal with friends or a romantic date night."
  • "Pizze one features a relaxed atmosphere with simplistic wall finishings, multiple electric in-wall fire places, good music, and stylish but comfortable seating."

Cons:

  • "It is freezing inside so bundle up."
  • "There were tiny flies all around us inside the restaurant which made me sick."
  • "Wasn't the best place to bring a small family due to where we were seated."
  • "We went in for a vegan pizza and we got one. It was excruciatingly bad the cheese was a gooey mess and the vegan pepperoni was not much better."
  • "The looks of the restaurant was quickly diminished by the service I received today."
  • "We waited 40 minutes for 3 appetizers to come out so we couldn’t even order a main meal."
  • "The truffle fries were ice cold and had way too much Parmesan cheese on it."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.