My Pie Pizzeria Romana Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Absolutely amazing pizza! I enjoyed the Pesto Pizza. It was baked very well, the cheese was perfectly melted, and the balance of the different ingredients was great."
• "Crispy crust, fresh basil, delicious tomatoes, amazing cheese."
• "Every slice packs distinct flavors that are memorable."
• "The truffle oil and mushroom slice met and exceeded my expectations."
• "The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, providing the ideal foundation for the generous toppings."
• "The sauce and cheese are out of this world."
• "The pizzas were so flavourful, packed with toppings."

Cons:

• "Even though the slice of pizza was tasty, it wasn’t memorable and I wouldn’t come back because there’s always a wait."
• "However, the buffalo chicken pizza was really disappointing. The sauce had an intense sour taste..."
• "The toppings were average."
• "This was not tasty WHATSOEVER."
• "There is a strange sour tangy taste in their sauce which was a turn off to me."
• "The mushroom could use more cheese and less mushrooms."
• "Pizza didn’t even have a tasty sauce or cheese to it."

Service

Pros:

• "Arrived nearly at closing with hungry kids and were greeted with such a friendly staff."
• "The employees are also lovely!"
• "The people here are amazing as well."
• "What made this pizzeria stand out for me was the employees. They were so kind."
• "The staff is super friendly and very proud of their organic and natural ingredients."
• "Best customer service. The lady at the counter is super sweet and bubbly."
• "The staffs are very helpful, we are tourist in USA and still haven't work out the coins yet, the staff helped us to work it out."

Cons:

• "talk about a bad night. had a slice and a half of the mushroom truffle pizza yesterday and boy did I feel it hurt my stomach and come out .. wouldn't trust the freshness of this place.. still in pain"
• "Heyva is a rude girl, she should shut up when she already took the order, let the other person work."
• "Pro-tip: Make sure you are prepared with your order because the staff can get a little spicy. 😉"
• "The multi person process to order, heat up, pay and get your food can be a bit awkward and slow, especially when its busy e the lunch crunch."

Price

Pros:

• "Good prices."
• "Prices are amazing for this authentic Italian pizza!"
• "Fast and friendly service, delicious pizza and fair prices."
• "$4 gets you two perfect squares of vegan, vegetarian, or any sort of gourmet pizza you could want."
• "The pricing is fair and standard for a pizza."
• "It's not cheap pizza, but compared to the quality it's a great price!"
• "The prices are reasonable for Manhattan and the service was great definitely well recommended."

Cons:

• "A bit overpriced but I can live with it."
• "I wasn't expecting to spend $9 for a slice of pizza and a can of soda."
• "$5.95 for a slice plus tax off course NYC cash cow lol."
• "I personally found the price to be pricier $ +bit steep."
• "It’s a bit spendy for pizza but you’ll know where the money went."

Ambiance

Pros:

• "Small cozy cute neighborhood pizza place with great air conditioning."
• "Perfect A/C for the summer days, it’s a refugee haha."
• "Beautiful tile work on the floor and old world woodwork around the outside walls."
• "The place is tidy with a cute interior."

Cons:

• "Very small place with 6 2-person tables along the walls, so don't expect to do much more than down a slice or pickup."
• "Seating is limited and pretty uncomfortable as well. Definitely a takeout place unless you go at an off hours time."
• "The inside of this establishment is super small and the tables and chairs are insanely small."
• "Beware, there is only seating for four people here. It gets uncomfortably crowded."
• "Only downside to the restaurant that I noticed is the very scant dining area."

Variety

Pros:

• "As a non-dairy consumer, they have 2 different pizza options that were very flavourful."
• "Also so good that they do multiple vegan options."
• "They also have vegan cheese pizza, and variety of imported soft drinks from Italy."
• "They have many different types of slices that are truly unique."
• "Great vegan options."
• "They have many different varieties of pizza each day that are refreshed constantly."
• "Great recipes for vegan pizza with no cheese."

Cons:

• "The pie was quite nice. It was the end of the day so fairly slim pickings in terms of choice if you wanted a slice rather than commission a whole new pizza."
• "There was just one downside they ran out of potatoes for one of the pizzas."
• "But if you go for dinner like we did they'll be out of most of the options, so you won't know what they have until you arrive."