McKinney & Doyle Corner Bakery & Fine Foods Cafe Reviews Summary

Category: Restaurant

Address: 10 Charles Colman Blvd, Pawling, NY 12564, USA

Phone: +18458553707

Rating: 4.6
based on 146 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The cheesecake is a 11 out of 10 stars."
  • "From the drinks to the sides everything is always 5 stars."
  • "THE CHEF DEFINITELY LOVES CREATING DECADENT SINFUL MASTERPIECES AS MUCH AS I LOVE EATING."
  • "And the food… OMG! My Bison burger was yummy, cook to perfection, allowing me to taste every single flavor."
  • "The food is fantastic the wait staff are very friendly. I have eaten there many times I never had a bad meal."
  • "The food is always fresh and delicious."
  • "The food was superb. In particular the Maine Lobster Risotto entree was a standout - I’m still thinking about it!"

Cons:

  • "We purchased baked goods for the holidays and the pies were raw."
  • "The smokehouse omelette was dry."
  • "The meal lacked salt and flavoring."
  • "The meat was like chewing rubber and it was extremely difficult to cut with a steak knife, as well as no seasoned flavor in the meat."
  • "The meal was OK- my son had a vegetable side dish that was so salty it was inedible."
  • "The trout had no taste because the lemon they used overpowered it."
  • "Meat in the turkey cranberry sandwich was rubber."

Service

Pros:

  • "A big THANK YOU to the Bakery team for helping me get the perfect cake for my husband's birthday!"
  • "The staff there was excellent, very cordial, and stayed on top with our needs."
  • "Served by an exceptional server who clearly loves her job and giving the experience the human dimension."
  • "Our sever Tori was great as was all the staff. Attentive, pleasant and nicely upscale."
  • "The entire staff made an effort to come over to our table and acknowledge our event."
  • "The staff was exceptional."
  • "Service is great even on the busiest nights."

Cons:

  • "There was no compensation for the mistake or our wait other than the kitchen lost our order."
  • "Our server was not very friendly either."
  • "Once seated waited another 20 minutes before we had to flag down a waitress for out drink order."
  • "We sat for 20 minutes while THREE girls behind the counter chatted to each other and never acknowledged us."
  • "Overall the service was on the slow side."
  • "Server left and never came back."
  • "When our waitress finally came around she was not friendly at all and that is putting nicely."

Ambiance & Decor

Pros:

  • "Like taking a time machine back to the 50s, but with a modern twist on the food and drinks."
  • "THE HOSTESS STAND WORKS DILIGENTLY TO AN AGED BRICK BACKDROP."
  • "I love the little quotes on the walls and the decor."
  • "It’s a very cute place and a very nice atmosphere."
  • "DECORATED WITH VINTAGE LITTLE SAYINGS ACROSS THE WALLS."
  • "I love the cozy atmosphere. Brick walls, old wood, and vintage pieces."
  • "DECORATED IN OLD CLASSIC CHARM WITH WORKED AND DISTRESSED MOST LIKELY ORIGINAL HARD WOOD FLOORS."

Cons:

  • "The decor doesn't fit with the quality that you are getting."
  • "Cold atmosphere."
  • "The only disappointing things are they change the custom drink menus often so you might not come back a see the same drink again."

Price & Value

Pros:

  • "They also have a bakery that is very reasonably priced, we order from there when we don't have time to bake for our family events."
  • "The restaurant offers rustic and casual, dining with delicious entrees at affordable prices."
  • "Bakery has very reasonable prices, cheese danishes, sticky buns, chocolate chip cookies, bagels, cakes, pies and more."
  • "Their dishes and drinks are also reasonably priced. Might seem a little high however the quality of the food is excellent."
  • "The menu options will please every palette and it’s high quality food is reasonably priced."

Cons:

  • "Restaurant is high quality food but also high prices expect to pay $50 for a dish."
  • "Great menu, however abit pricey. We all loved our choices, so it was worth the trip from Danbury."
  • "Pricey."
  • "Way too expensive."
  • "The chips and guacamole are also amazing and delicious, but... a little overpriced in our opinion."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.