Address: 340 Lafayette St, New York, NY 10012, USA
Phone: +19174643746
Rating: 4.7
based on 319 reviews.
Cookie Quality
Pros:
"A solid high-quality cookie that is a must-try if you're in the area."
"These cookies are easily a pound, and they are so decadent and so delicious."
"The cookies are crispy but chewy, and the velvety and gooey center makes these cookies unforgettable."
"Their cookies are substantial servings of gooey (read: perfectly 'underbaked') goodness."
"The cookies are giant mounds of gooeyness with a crispy enough shell."
"These cookies are amazing & perfectly baked crunchy on the outside & soft in the insides."
"The cookies are generously packed with rich chocolate chips, creating a delightful, gooey center that contrasts beautifully with the slightly crispy exterior."
Cons:
"I was a little disappointed by a particularly flat classic chocolate chip cookie. It was a little crunchy, in a bad way."
"Other pastries here don't seem as good though - price is high and they're not particularly out of this world."
"The recipe seems off for some reason."
"I really liked the original one but today I tried the gluten free one the whole cookie was too soft and fell apart when you grab them in hands.. the inside is almost like liquid with just a bit of crunch on the outside."
"But it was too sweet for my taste."
"They don’t taste like a typical chocolate chip cookie as in it doesn’t have that brown sugar molassesy texture but a little less moist and toned down in flavour for the actual dough."
"The double chocolate chip was too sweet without enough variety of ingredients or enough heartiness."
Customer Service
Pros:
"Had some AMAZING customer service."
"The service is quick, kind and they bring a great genuine energy to the experience."
"Always so friendly and efficient, even when there's a line out the door!"
"Service is top notch with exceedingly friendly employees!"
"The staff were super nice, friendly & with big smiles! Excellent service!"
"The staff was super friendly and nice it was my first time there and they were so patient with me and gave me the best suggestions!!"
"The service was excellent and fast."
Cons:
"This location seems very understaffed and unfocused which is a shame given how lovely the baked goods are."
"It shouldn't take the team ten - fifteen minutes to serve the three customers ahead of me."
"Why did i give it a 4/5, because one of the guys working at the counter got angry because i wanted to change the order."
"It was very crowded so I can't entirely blame the workers, but the service could have been a little more friendly."
"Servers overwhelmed and lack basic training to write down verbal requests."
"Horrendous customer service."
"Staff was a bit unfriendly."
Price and Value
Pros:
"They were large and 100% worth the price."
"When you get a $5 cookie, you have high expectations and man they did not miss."
"It is very filling and for the price I think it is worth it."
"Cookies are huge so it’s worth the price."
"A bit pricey but imo worth it."
"Cookies are expensive though - 5 dollars per cookie! But for huge cookies, worth it."
"So, with no hesitation, I will pay $5 to get one of those cookies again."
Cons:
"First, I saw the prices. And I told myself: woahhh, it’s kind of expensive!"
"Quite pricey but worth the cost per cookie given size too."
"Cookies are expensive though - 5 dollars per cookie!"
"I also found it presumptive that the till asked for a 18% + tip on handing us two cookies."
"$15 for 3 mouths full of…Nope."
"Ever paid $5+ for a single cookie? Well here your chance, you’ll probably get to wait inline as well!!"
"$15 I won't get back, time in line I won't get back either."
Atmosphere and Decor
Pros:
"Love the atmosphere and the decor of this location."
"Really nice spot for enjoying some cookies after a long day in Soho."
"The location is nice."
"The decor is cute and fun."
"The location is absolutely adorable as well."
"The ambiance is inviting."
"The atmosphere in here is great and it doesn't feel pretentious either."
Cons:
"Because of Covid there is no indoor seating, so be prepared to take it to go."
"This branch is really busy and there’s not a lot of room to eat in."
"There were a couple of spots to sit and eat but it seemed like it was a place that you would take your order to go."
"Limited seating (no tables) so more of a grab and go option."
"Very crowded bakery, don’t expect to sit down for a relaxed coffee and cookie."
"Only problem was too crowded. I had to pick with rushing."
"To bad we cannot sit inside, it would have been nice to enjoy the cookie seated right after but it’s ok."