Blue Moon Mexican Cafe Reviews Summary

Category: Mexican restaurant

Address: 327 Franklin Ave Suite J, Wyckoff, NJ 07481, USA

Phone: +12018911331

Rating: 4.2
based on 117 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Always delicious. Tastes very fresh every time we go."
  • "The enchilada was very good."
  • "The buffalo shrimp fajita was delicious and you can't complain about unlimited free chips and fresh salsa."
  • "The food seems to be the same, both consistently very good."
  • "Food is INSANELY GOOD no matter what you order."
  • "The food was hot and delicious…we stayed warm and enjoyed our dining in these crazy times."
  • "The food was excellent! I got a perfectly cooked burger & my husband got a bowl of chili."

Cons:

  • "I threw the whole nachos in the garbage I ordered chicken and steak nachos they left out the steak I only had maybe 10 nachos buried in nasty tasting hot sauce I wasted $20."
  • "I got the shrimp tacos. Very greasy no flavor."
  • "The food, however, is not that great. I have eaten here several times and each time, the meals were devoid of any flavor."
  • "Oh my God the worst good I've eaten in my life."
  • "The food was salty and mediocre."
  • "Both burritos were dry and mediocre."
  • "The refried beans had a burnt taste, the taco was all oil on the plate and the chimichanga was soggy - nothing had a decent taste."

Service

Pros:

  • "The staff were prompt and friendly."
  • "Staff is always super friendly and smiling."
  • "It is very clean and the staff are very friendly and attentive."
  • "The staff here was super attentive."
  • "Service was awesome, food was great and prepared very quickly."
  • "The service was EXCELLENT!"
  • "Staff is incredibly polite and we always have a great experience."

Cons:

  • "First it's extremely loud and noisy. Awful 70's classic rock was depressing and painful to listen to."
  • "Food was ok but the service was horrible first and last time I ever come here."
  • "Horrible service: ordered appetizers and it took over 45 mins to come out."
  • "No point in a happy hour where drinks are straight juice and watered down πŸ˜–"
  • "The service was slow sadly."
  • "Service was not good. Our order was delivered with lots of errors."
  • "Worst service I have ever experienced in my entire life."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "They had the outside capabilities to seat guests because they had heaters and tables."
  • "Great ambiance, good food, nice location for after meal shopping or walks in the Boulder Run Shopping center."
  • "The atmosphere is fun & casual."
  • "Environment is great and welcoming."
  • "The outside patio is nice."
  • "The ambiance was better suited for a country bar."
  • "The dining room is very comfortable with soft lighting and it never seems overly loud inside."

Cons:

  • "The place is a little small, and cramped..."
  • "Dining room was dirty and sticky."
  • "Just be warned, on weekends it can get crowded and loud!"
  • "A somewhat better strip mall restaurant with ordinary decore."
  • "Had a terrible experience, food was bland and dining room was mess!"
  • "We went to dinner last night and it was quite cold outside, and inside it appeared to be close to maximum occupancy."
  • "They were very attentive, it's just such a big room with very little in it to absorb the sound."

Value

Pros:

  • "Prices were reasonable, & they accept credit cards."
  • "Highly recommended if you enjoy eating sizable portions of delicious Mexican food at very reasonable prices."
  • "Prices were moderate."
  • "Blue Moon provides very large portions at a reasonable price."
  • "The portions are large which is nice for the price."
  • "Generous portions of delicious food."
  • "The meals are fairly priced."

Cons:

  • "I wasted $20."
  • "Not the cheapest place to eat but with the trip."
  • "Considering how much the prices have jumped it's a bit outrageous I just cant see paying almost $20 for a basic salad w/ chicken!"
  • "$16 for small guacamole πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚ Ridiculous!!!"
  • "First time and most likely last time ordering from here. It is over priced and VERY bland."
  • "Definitely not worth the $40 we paid for dinner. Highly disappointed."
  • "Price went up! Not much to enjoy about it anymore."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.