Address: 36 Eagle Rock Ave, East Hanover, NJ 07936, USA
Phone: +19738874442
Rating: 4.6
based on 161 reviews.
Food Quality
Pros:
"food is fantastic."
"Ordered this custom cake from the bakery for my daughter's bday... it was very nicely done with good quality and taste was awesome."
"Sorrentos has the best pastries and desserts in the area."
"Best Italian Bakery & Deli Around! Phenomenal Italian Sandwiches, Delicious Pastries of all kinds, Amazing Fresh Italian Bread & the Italian Cold Cuts are Top Notch."
"Their strawberry short cake is delicious and to die far."
"Their cakes, pies and pastries are very good."
"The food was probably the best sandwiches we've had in a very long time!!"
Cons:
"I was very disappointed with the Rum Cake, which has been my favorite for over 15 years."
"The cake was definitely stale."
"also the tiramisu tasted like soap."
"Bread was also dry and I’m guessing they tried to make up for everything being dry with about 10 ounces of balsamic vinegar."
"We just bought a cake with mocha yesterday to celebrate our friends daughter's birthday but nobody like to eat it because it has too much sugar and the cake was definitely stale."
"The butter roll was stale and hard."
"The cake is very dry and taste like lemon (when it’s not supposed to be lemon!)."
Customer Service
Pros:
"I stopped by for lunch & was greeted promptly by a lady in the bakery section (she's the reason I gave 3 stars)."
"There are always plenty of employees working, so even at its busiest, you never wait long to be served."
"The employees are friendly and helpful."
"The staff are so lovely and helpful. They doted on my 2 year old son and even shrink wrapped a sandwich for us to take in our suitcase."
"The staff are friendly and quick. Lines can get long but they keep it pushing without being rude."
"The entire staff is super friendly and all the pastry is amazing!"
"Great People behind the deli and bakery counters! They made a stranger from Texas feel right at-home."
Cons:
"food is fantastic but the service is HORRIBLE."
"No one was willing to wait even 5 extra minutes for me to come collect it."
"I was totally ignored by workers."
"Absolutely horrible. A custom cake for my sons Bday… garbage."
"The staff here can be rude hence the 4 star review."
"Never Again waited almost 10 mins to get served."
"The deli area has a terrible attitude."
Facility & Cleanliness
Pros:
"Very clean bakery, friendly & attentive staff so the lines keep moving."
"This place was incredible, the line moved quickly, very organized, clean atmosphere, and extremely pleasant staff and customers who were patient and very helpful!"
"Clean, easy to get to, allergy conscious and inexpensive."
"The presentation is beautiful, quality is alright, but the attendants OMG ..they almost hit you get off the line extremely rude and unprofessional."
"Handicap parking is accessible."
"You can also shop for your favorite Italian imported food while there."
"A true Italian bakery. All of your bakery needs plus so much more."
Cons:
"Sorry no restrooms."
"The inside was good but designed by amateurs."
"There are usually a lot of people, but not many parking spaces."
"During the lunch rush it can take anywhere from 10 to 20 minutes before you place your order and another 5 to 10 for the sandwich to be made and for you to pay."
"With over 30 people crammed in there, some of the food handlers were not wearing mask And ignored customers requests to put on a mask."
"Overall was pretty bad tbh. One and done!!"
"When I visited this location it was not welcoming."