Clinton Hall Reviews Summary

Category: Beer garden New York

Address: 16 W 36th St., New York, NY 10018, USA

Phone: +12126950036

Rating: 4.2
based on 140 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Food was good."
  • "The food was good tasting and the old school table games to play are cool."
  • "For food, you have to try the doughnut grilled cheese (it’s literally a grilled cheese sandwich, but with a doughnut) or the fondue burger."
  • "I had the chicken tacos and they were perfection."
  • "We had the WTF waffle. It was amazing."
  • "The food was amazing."
  • "The food is super good."

Cons:

  • "The portions were pretty small given the prices."
  • "The fries taste extremely low grade."
  • "The burgers took forever to come out and our Fondue burger was even given to the people seated at the bar by mistake."
  • "The food is ok nothing the rave about, the portion is large."
  • "It was not fondue cheese but cheese wiz."
  • "Food was served cold and took forever to arrive nor was it made the way it was described on the menu."
  • "What an over hyped burger..just get the fries and cheese as a side rather than a hole in the burger with a few fries sticking out."

Service

Pros:

  • "Our bartender was Leo great guy very high spirits made fantastic margaritas definitely recommend!"
  • "Our servers for the night were Adam and Julio... They were so attentive and accommodating - our entire group loved having them around the whole night."
  • "Employees are very helpful. Waitress helped with our order and even looked up a drink I liked to make sure I could have my drink."
  • "The employees were very nice and helpful."
  • "The service was really good."
  • "Staff polite & attentive."
  • "Waiters friendly."

Cons:

  • "Server was very off, forgot to ring in food, and then proceeded to lie about it."
  • "This guy doesn't know how to communicate with patrons or is even interested in having a conversation."
  • "Bartender was rude and apparently it was her first day so I don’t know why she was taking shots with customers and had an attitude all the time."
  • "The waitress we had was among the worst waitresses I've ever had."
  • "The service was a little slow because there were only two waitresses during a busy lunch time."
  • "The waiter repeatedly made passive aggressive remarks."
  • "The service is slow to non existent."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "WAY better than it has any right to be, given the location."
  • "Fun place to go with friends. Nice selection of beers and AMAZING food!"
  • "Venue was awesome. Love the board game concept."
  • "Great hangout atmosphere. A perfect place to meet up with friends."
  • "Cool atmosphere with games all around - appeared to be a college hang out."
  • "The atmosphere is very chill, spacious and welcoming."
  • "Very cool place to have a good time with friends and family."

Cons:

  • "The hostess on Saturday at 6:45pm made us feel so immediately unwelcome that we just left."
  • "VERY LOUD VERY BUSY."
  • "Music was extremely loud even for a large bar — could have been 20 dB quieter and it still would have been piercing."
  • "Music is overbearing."
  • "Another less-than-stellar Clinton Hall location. Service was very inadequate overall, and the large room was filled with a gloomy vibe on an otherwise pretty Saturday afternoon."
  • "Not too busy and no one was really playing any games."
  • "The perfect place, but the education of the person who is controlling the entrance, terrible."

Value

Pros:

  • "Decently priced and quality food."
  • "A varied beer list that has excellent craft beer for a reasonable price, and a great menu that doesn’t suffer from Midtown pricing."
  • "The taster flights are great value and let you choose any 4 beers from their Supercraft range."
  • "If you are getting shots of vodka added to your $11 ginger beer for $3 you’re getting a great deal on the vodka!"
  • "The drinks were reasonably priced for the location it is in."
  • "Moderately priced."
  • "Best burger I've EVER had and the only place that makes decent, well-seasoned, well cooked fries."

Cons:

  • "Drinks...not strong and very pricey."
  • "You now need to pay an additional $7 for fries by ordering them separately."
  • "Paid $394.00 plus a $455 drink tab minimum for three appetizers and to reserve a table for a party of twenty then got a table that only sat ten."
  • "Some beers were actually expensive even for NYC standard."
  • "The burgers no longer include fries!! DEVASTATING."
  • "Overpriced to a pretty high degree so it felt more like a bar than a food hall."
  • "They charged us $2 for a drink on the rocks. Really? $2 for an ice cube?"

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.