Watermark Reviews Summary

Service

Pros:

• "Gil was the best!!! Thank you for amazing service and for a great time."
• "Service was great."
• "The service was quick and efficient."
• "Our server Jessica was amazing and super helpful when asking about the menu and drinks!!"
• "The service was amazing! Shoutout to Korra for seating us and Paula and Kiran for being the best!"
• "Our server Camila was incredibly kind and helpful in what to order!"
• "Our server Lizzy was the sweetest!"

Cons:

• "Waiter wasn’t around too often."
• "Servers take a while to get back to you."
• "As I arrived, I stood by the host stand for two minutes as I waited for the hosts to finish their personal conversation."
• "It was hell trying to flag a server down to order food."
• "We didn't have a server for about 25 minutes before we had to flag a person down."
• "Service is slow, takes a while for a waiter to get to your tiny table."
• "It was difficult to settle the situation at the pop up itself due to the staff not being available."

Food

Pros:

• "The food was superb as well."
• "The food was delicious. The cocktails were delicious and beautifully decorated."
• "Our experience was so wonderful. The food was delicious."
• "The lobster Mac and cheese was amazing."
• "The food was good and the watermelon margarita was good as well."
• "The food was well portioned and delicious."
• "The food was all delicious!"

Cons:

• "Food came cold at 2:25. They were out of crabcakes."
• "We ordered 6 chicken sliders which the amount of chicken all together from each slider wouldn’t even make up 1 whole chicken breast, it was too breaded and not to mention dry."
• "The food wasn’t bad but it’s nothing to scream about either."
• "Food is a bit overpriced for the quality."
• "The menu was blahhhh- nothing looked appetizing and the portion sizes are small."
• "The food was basic, pink for the holiday but basic."
• "The food was subpar. The salmon was dry and lack flavor."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "The place is really nice. Nice atmosphere."
• "Love this spot right, it's on the pier so of course the breeze from the ocean is wonderful."
• "Most people come for the airy ambience and the view."
• "This is the perfect place to spend happy hour on a nice day."
• "A delightful winter wonderland visit this Christmas!"
• "The Pink Pier has a wonderful atmosphere, made even better by the kind and efficient staff."
• "The atmosphere the view of Brooklyn on a beautiful New York sunday awesome best enjoyed in a group setting."

Cons:

• "The place is small and they do not know where they are."
• "It's not meant for grown ups at all, it's cramped and there's nothing to do."
• "It’s nice that it’s outdoor, but not really a great view."
• "It was overcrowded when we went and super cold."
• "Nice theme cool view but food is blahhh or mediocre at best."
• "It was raining and water was getting in."
• "The only well light area is the entrance."

Value

Pros:

• "Definitely worth going."
• "Also the food was fantastic and I felt the prices were incredible for the quality."
• "Not bad prices either, <$50 for a stein and 1L pour pretty reasonable for Manhattan."
• "I got ticket for $40 at QuietEvents.com which I thought was a bit expensive, but there was over 400 people and the party was crazy, so TOTALLY WORTH IT."
• "Easily one of the best places to visit when you’re in the area!"
• "A fun place to go with a group of friends! Especially during the summer."
• "We went here for the 4th of July celebration special event. Well worth the expense."

Cons:

• "Do not waste your money like we did."
• "Everything was an extra cost on the of the $300 you already paid. Even whipped cream on your hot chocolate."
• "Drinks absolutely overpriced."
• "The worst thing is that you have to walk to the exit to go to the bathroom."
• "For the money, I didn't think there was much value in the food we were served."
• "How pathetic, total rip off."
• "The worst of all is that everything is very expensive compared to other places of higher quality."

Facilities

Pros:

• "The view is mind blowing! Price is right just to be able to relax outside watching over the Hudson with a few drinks was very humbling!"
• "The views were impeccable."
• "The view here was just breathtaking!"
• "Awesome views. One of the best places to visit, relax and enjoy the beautiful views of lower downtown, the Brooklyn Bridge and area."
• "This waterfront restaurant is a fun hangout spot with views of Brooklyn Bridge and some skyline."
• "Mainly great for the scenic view!"
• "It’s beautiful spot with great views."

Cons:

• "There are two toilets for the whole pier, if you need to go, you wait forever and it is the grossest bathroom I have ever seen."
• "The restaurant also doesn't have its own bathroom."
• "It takes 2 minutes to see the entire place. There are no activities."
• "The winter wonderland was a disappointment. So small and nothing to see."
• "Aside from taking pictures, I wouldn’t go back."
• "One handfull of fries is 8$, Mac and Cheese would not even be enough for a kid."
• "We got the unlimited drink (beer and wine) package, and waited on a line for a full hour to get 1 drink."