Address: 556 N State, 3008, 556 NJ-17, Paramus, NJ 07652, USA
Phone: +12014473999
Rating: 4.3
based on 146 reviews.
Service & Staff
Pros:
"Their service and staff are great."
"The guys there are very welcoming and I love the atmosphere."
"The staff is very kind and prompt."
"Greg and the rest of the staff are professional, courteous and most importantly friendly."
"The staff is friendly, attentive, and polite."
"The staff at Anthony Franco's are awesome."
"The staff is super friendly and fast."
Cons:
"The person on the phone was super rude, telling a lie, looking down, you name it!"
"Whoever the girl is answering their phones at 11am doesn’t know how to treat customers."
"Wouldn't trust someone like this to hire staff making my food."
"Stay away from this place... they would make you ashamed for trying to figure out why they charged you extra."
"Unprofessional and rude. I called just to see where our lunch order is and a girl answered and told me deliveries are running late."
"The 'manager' was rude from the beginning and it only got worse."
"So amazingly RUDE. Customer service is totally lacking."
Food Quality
Pros:
"The best pizza. Each pie is loaded with cheese and toppings, and always perfectly cooked."
"I go here for their buffalo chicken pizza. The chicken completely covers the pizza."
"The food, whether bruschetta, pizza or chicken marsala, is delicious and freshly made."
"The quality of their veal, chicken, seafood and all ingredients is top notch."
"The quality of food is exceptional and all staff members love the items on the menu."
"Their food is always very well made, from pizzas to pastas and salads."
"The food is fantastic and made with precision and care."
Cons:
"Ordered a chicken parm sandwich, (fatty and chewy) (barely any sauce and globbed with unmelted cheese)."
"The food was ok my sandwich bread was soggy and fries seemed like they need to change the oil in the fryer."
"This is so unsanitary."
"The wings literally have no chicken on them, the finger fingers were like rubber and the meatballs tasted store bought."
"This past week, I ordered a chicken dinner and it smelled awful."
"All the three appetizers are horrible calamari like rubber zucchini not even appetizing garlic knots are extremely hard."
"Meatball & Spaghetti soup, wish a lasagna dish and chicken parm that was stale they should just close the doors or get a real chef."
Delivery & Timeliness
Pros:
"We also have them cater a lot of our parties and no one is ever disappointed."
"They went above and beyond to deliver delicious, hot food."
"Their delivery service is quick and professional."
"Delivery is always on time and fresh."
Cons:
"Placed an order, was told 45 mins to an hour for delivery... Over an hour and 45 minutes I called again and they said it would be there soon. When it finally arrived, the driver was aloof and unapologetic."
"Tonight we ordered food at 6:40 -paid over the phone- they told me it would be around 40 minutes. It was now after 8:00 and the order still has not arrived."
"Ordered 2 buffalo chicken slices and am extremely disappointed for paying $4 a slice."
"Upon delivery it was still incorrect."
"The delivery person was also super rude and unprofessional."
Value & Pricing
Pros:
"The fact that they keep their prices in line with other local pizzerias provides great value to their patrons."
"Prices were decent, food was done fast and it was absolutely fantastic."
"Delicious food, generous portions, great location, spacious store, pleasant employees, reasonable prices - everything you want for lunch or dinner."
"It is fairly economical as well."
Cons:
"Used to visit once a month for past 15 years or so but that ends tonight. Understand we are in inflationary times but $16.56 for a cheese pizza to go?"
"Food is average, but the scamming they do with the amount that they charge you is bordering to scamming scheme."
"A pie and a large salad was $40, you can get better quality from elsewhere. Wasn’t worth the money."
"A tad expensive but quality food and open an hour later than any other pizzeria-restaurant."
Cleanliness & Atmosphere
Pros:
"Restaurant itself is clean with a fun atmosphere."
"It's a pizzeria that is usually for the most part pretty clean."
"The place is always clean and food is fresh."
"Amazing atmosphere as well."
Cons:
"It’s always cold in there and they leave the door open and you get a ton of flies buzzing around you when your trying to eat."
"This isn't to come at the pizza, but the way I observed the food being handled is unacceptable for a food establishment."
"The restaurant is dirty, just look at the ceilings and soda machine."