"5 stars across the board, incredible. Fantastic stuff Patsy's."
"Food was incredible and our service was even better."
"The pizza was absolutely delicious that I completely forgot to take any photos!"
"Excellent black squid ink pasta with mixed seafood. Baked clams were fresh and very tasty."
"The Margherita pizza was delicious. Simple but with good ingredients and perfectly cooked just how pizza was meant to be."
"Their brick oven pizza was delightful and their ricotta cheese cheesecake was better than I imagined."
"The food is always on point."
Cons:
"Sadly, I think the food here was very mediocre."
"The pasta dish I ordered was not fresh. It was reheated, and they didn’t even do that properly because the food was still cold in some places."
"Food was below average. We got the margarita pie, which was bland and had no flavor whatsoever."
"It tasted factory-made. And was very expensive."
"Margarita pizza was good, another one was crazy salty."
"Very disappointed with our dinner. We ordered Meat Ball Param and Chicken Param. The Meat Ball Param was one meat ball sliced and the chicken Param was over cooked and tuff."
"The pizza was mediocre at best & gave me diarrhea."
Service
Pros:
"The staff is always friendly and attentive."
"Service was impeccable."
"Service was A+ loved our waiter. Incredibly attentive and friendly."
"The service was good, waiters were polite. Overall a great experience with their outdoor patio."
"Service was exceptional. Real New York pizza at it's finest!"
"Service is fantastic as well."
"Service was excellent! Friendly, attentive, and available."
Cons:
"The food was okay, but the service wasn't good."
"Orders fried calamari and two beers which they never brought, the waiter was very rude."
"Our waiter never brought any bread to the table while waiting for our food, and only checked on us once."
"Poor service. Pizza arrived several minutes before drinks. Then sides arrive five minutes later."
"The bartender was serving us and his service was nonexistent."
"For some reason the servers did not offer us the free bread they offered to everyone else."
"Was placed all the way back of the restaurant. waiters check upon us when we didn't need them several times but when we needed them none were to be found."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"It's a really comfortable atmosphere, makes you feel like you're at a friends house."
"Loved the authentic old style decor, such a warm feeling."
"What a wonderful place! Great pizza, gorgeous atmosphere, friendly staff, what more could you ask for?"
"The place is very elegant and comfortable, offering lunch specials and happy hour."
"Walking into Patsy's you can expect three things: great pizza, you'll be treated like family, and you won't want to leave."
"It's an easy place to love..."
"We were greeted by great people behind the bar and were seated in a beautiful back sort of inside patio space."
Cons:
"Lighting was slightly dim, the only thing I didn't love about the atmosphere."
"Backyard part of the restaurant is basically nice, but at night time lighting is not comfortable."
"The main dining room is in a temporary structure with heaters. The interior was fine, but it's not really the nicest restaurant around."
"Not much to criticize other than a few flies strolling around."
"The ambience was dull. I can see why it was half empty."
Value
Pros:
"Gosh golly this is some good pizza. Second best in New York after Prince Street."
"I’ve been all over the world and eaten a lot of pizzas and the Margarita pizza at Patsys next to Barclays center is still my favorite pizza."
"Have ordered from them five times- EVERYTHING has been delicious, just perfect!"
"Spaghetti and meatballs, oysters and gnocchi a la sorrentina for meals. Good food decent price."
"Good food decent price."
"The pizza was pretty good and it was inexpensive."
"No problem bought a small pie n it was worth every bite"
Cons:
"Could be overpriced. They handed us the check, and it already included a 20% (gratuity) tip."
"Unbelievable for nearly $40, and I didn't even finish the leftovers."
"I always like Patsy's, but I always want to invest more money after the bill comes because it will break your wallet."
"Pizza's Prices are a bit high."
"Pizzas are above average but over priced."
"For $22 it barely covered the bottom of the Tupperware and the vodka sauce was very very watery."
"Quality is decreasing and the service is absolutely awful!"