"ABSOLUTELY, without any doubt, Tacconelli's Pizzeria is one of the top 3 Family owned, operated, and serving superior quality pizza to Philadelphians for decades."
"Their pizza is so delicious!! We were watching the Vice channel and saw a show about some of the best pizza places to go to. Tacconelli's was one of them."
"Best pizza I’ve ever had by a long shot. Ordered the traditional red pizza as ‘well done’. Nice and crispy crust, minimal grease, perfect flavor in the sauce, amazing cheese."
"The pizza is incredible. The red pie with pepperoni and onion!!?? I might drive an hour for it.. Let's not mention the amazing signature pie with The garlic and spinach."
"Thin Crust crispy crunch with every bite. Perfect blend of sauce cheese and crust."
"Definitely the best local pizza in Maple Shade!"
"The pizza, if you’re a fan of thin crust, oh my! The red sauce was so flavorful, perfect crisp on the crust, yum yum and yum!"
Cons:
"Got radiatore pasta with gorgonzala. Bland, tasted like cream."
"The white pie could have used more 'white.' There was no ricotta & very little mozzarella."
"Pizza has to be one of the worst I've had."
"Upon opening the box, I was repulsed by the pizza's appearance... The flavor was rather bland and I felt like I wasn't eating anything at all."
"Pizza I had was overly salty and garlicy."
"The food was gross. Will not return."
"It was terrible the Caesar salad was so dry the signature Pizza came out burnt so they made another one and that was even some burnt."
Service
Pros:
"Bring your drinks, it’s a byob, and service was amazing!"
"Staff was very busy but still great job."
"Staff polite, professional, and friendly."
"Our waitress, Savanah, was amazing just like all the wait staff there!!!"
"Staff was incredible."
"Our server was friendly, accurate and gave great recommendations."
"Staff is very friendly and accommodating."
Cons:
"Servers did the absolute minimum and rushed us a bit."
"One of the hostesses was rushing us from the minute we were seated telling us that we had to order promptly even though we had only been seated a few minutes prior?"
"Staff not nice never been there before looking for the pic up counter and they way they responded when I asked it was like I should’ve known."
"Wait staff was a bit slow & could have been a bit more attentive."
"Pizza comes out of the oven and no one is there bring the pizza to you because the wait staff were busy mingling amongst themselves in the back corner by the kitchen entrance."
"Service isn't that great when you first walk in."
"Customer service is terrible (Maple Shade). Provided wrong order upon pickup."
Value
Pros:
"The prices are worth the perfection."
"Only $17 for an insanely awesome large pizza. I’ll for sure be coming back!"
"Price might make you wince when you think it's just pizza, but it's not. It's really really incredible, fresh pizza. It's 100% worth every penny."
"Only wish the pasta portions were bigger but we left paying only $50 with tip for a pasta entree, a whole pie and a dessert!"
"It's BYOB - which saves you some good money."
"Their pizza never fails me."
"The salad is always really fresh and the balsamic dressing is also really good."
Cons:
"High priced double anywhere else."
"Bang for your buck. The pizzas are small for the price."
"I am very Disappointed I paid 14. 67 for bread and sauce. The pizza was not all that at all."
"Overpriced foods. Nothing special..."
"For my taste the crab Mac and cheese is too salty."
"I was put off by the additional charges for simple things like cheese."
"3.5 out of 5. Pizza was alright, crust was burnt and not so great to eat and the 3 toppings we ordered were really scarce."
Ambience
Pros:
"The atmosphere is nicer than some pizza places, maybe that is why I see families gathering there."
"The ambience is warm and inviting and when you’re there you feel like it’s a real family operation."
"BYOB and cash only - very nice service and pleasant dining atmosphere."
"The restaurant is big and open so you don't feel cramped inside."
"Friendly waitstaff and warm and welcoming eatery for singles, groups or families."
"Spacious atmosphere. You gotta go and try out them out!"
"The warm, Italian atmosphere is inviting and a welcome change from most pizza places."
Cons:
"This place has really odd hours."
"It’s not a great experience, people are not really nice."
"It was nothing really spectacular."
"The service. The default is to rush you out the door."
"Reason for 1 review because we didn’t have reservations and were willing to wait... we should of been told that in entering not have to walk past everyone eating, the kitchen and everything else. Bad taste of service to me."
"Nearly the whole staff in the open air kitchen were mask less."
"Rude extremely rude."
Payment & Convenience
Pros:
"Bring your drinks, it’s a byob, and service was amazing!"
"The Restaurant is BYOB, but in my opinion that makes parties more easy!"
"The iced tea has holy water in it. Absolutely delicious And a great thirst quencher."
"We brought our own cake; as we were celebrating someone’s birthday; and they were super cool about it."
"Experience is always excellent. My adult son and I go there for dinner on most Sundays... Have never been disappointed in either our food or the service by the staff."
"Everything was amazing... the salad, pizza, and dessert was phenomenal!!!!"
"The service was fast and friendly and we ended the evening with some great desserts."
Cons:
"Doesn’t take debit or credit cards and ATM doesn’t work. Place has inconvenient hours."
"This place is CASH ONLY and I did not realize this until the bill came."
"This is the worst pizzeria in the area. Don'T LET THE REVIEWS FOOL YOU!!!!"
"Very rude and unprofessional."
"We waited so long for pizzas!"
"This time we waited nearly 30 minutes to get a piece of cake for dessert."
"We kept calling to make a reservation and no one would pick up the phone!"