Broad Nosh Bagels Deli & Catering 58th Street Reviews Summary

Quality of Bagels

Pros:

• "This is by far the best bagel shop I have ever been to!!!"
• "Got a plain bagel with scallion cream cheese, turkey, egg, and cheese toasted for less than $10!"
• "Their egg salad is so chunky and creamy at the same time, while their scallion cream cheese, the gold standard, is absolutely delectable."
• "The bread is one of the fluffiest I’ve ever tasted in the US and the taste is just over the top."
• "The bagel itself was fresh with a nice chew and had just the right ratio of cream cheese to bagel."
• "Our bagels were soft inside with a chewy crust - just like they should be."
• "The bagels were the best I’ve ever had. Absolutely perfect."

Cons:

• "Everything bagels continue to have no seeds on the bottom and a lackluster seed mix."
• "The eggs were a little dry."
• "The bagel was just average... I like my bagels to be chewy but this was not."
• "The bagels (both everything and seasame) lacked flavor and had almost no seeds on the bottom half."
• "Unfortunately the bagels here were dense and flat and the sausage dry so I can’t recommend."
• "Just wish they would season both sides of the bagel!"
• "The bagel itself was so plain."

Customer Service

Pros:

• "The owner is very personable and will make rounds, talking to customers."
• "The owner Robert is super friendly, very polite and respectful, and also knowledgeable."
• "The owner was walking around and constantly checking in on us to make sure we were okay, as well as his employees!"
• "Stopped by for a bagel and ended up leaving with a great memory. The owner, Robert, stopped by to say hello and we left with several tips about the city and some fantastic conversation."
• "The owner and staff couldn’t have been more friendly and welcoming."
• "Robert is so friendly and really takes cares of his customers!!!"
• "The staff are very attentive and helpful."

Cons:

• "The place itself was an absolute disaster (long wait times, orders out of place, etc)."
• "The person in charge berated one of his employees in front of all the customers for mistaking an order which made me feel uncomfortable."
• "The service however, has to be improved. The staff is extremely loud and borderline rude, not paying attention to you and your order, more focused on laughing between themselves."
• "i waited like ten minutes for a regular bagel. how do you have like 12 workers and it takes that long."
• "We ordered online and it still took an hour."
• "Made me wait for 40 min even though the online order said it was ready."
• "The atmosphere here blows... People bump into you when seated, the order pickup creates a clogged entrance, and the general vibe feels off."

Location and Atmosphere

Pros:

• "Can’t beat the location this close to Central Park."
• "A must visit when you are near Columbus Circle!"
• "This was a hidden gem near Columbus circle."
• "Perfectly located beside Central Park, and not too far from Broadway & Times Square."
• "The location is great, being so close to Central Park and multiple hotels in the area, and was easy to find."
• "It's a great location to pick up some Bagels and snacks as you picnic in Central Park."
• "Great location for grabbing a meal to go and eat in Columbus Circle or the park."

Cons:

• "Tiny shop with very limited seating, definitely recommend ordering ahead to take away."
• "Seating is limited though there are a good number of seats/tables."
• "The only downside was that there was not enough chairs and tables outside and the trash bin was overflowing."
• "Note that the place is very busy, so you may not have a spot to sit."
• "I have not place to sit but Central park half of block from here so You can enjoy your food with amazing Park View."
• "Overpriced Tours Spot not for real New Yorkers....Will never go back there again very disappointed."
• "The place itself has a real cozy vibe. It's perfect for a quick bite."

Value for Money

Pros:

• "Got a plain bagel with scallion cream cheese, turkey, egg, and cheese toasted for less than $10!"
• "The bagels are very recently priced if you just buy them plain without anything they are so fresh."
• "The bagels are good 🙂and great for the price."
• "Prices are more than reasonable for the quality."
• "Not bad prices considering it's location."
• "Fast efficient staff and a decent price."
• "Food was delicious. Prices were just right."

Cons:

• "Almost $9 for a BEC on a bagel, are you kidding me!!!"
• "Total cost for the bagel was $16-$17."
• "Price Changes in New York City are truly ridiculous now... It's not the place for me anymore. 40.00 dollars for Bagle lox and cream Chesse and an O.J"
• "Great bagels, the only thing is that they are pricey, as a meal, and you want quite long in a line to order."
• "The ink on their coffee mugs smears after one hand wash (pictured) and, after putting fresh coffee in it for the first time, is SUPER hot."