The Bagel Emporium of Tarrytown Reviews Summary

Category: Bagel shop

Address: 350 S Broadway, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA

Phone: +19143330033

Rating: 4.3
based on 139 reviews.

Bagel Quality

Pros:

  • "These bagels are really good and they have vegan cream cheese!"
  • "Their bagels are really soft on the inside and have this nice crust."
  • "Their bagels are excellent -- better than most you find in NYC."
  • "Some of the best bagels I have eaten."
  • "The bagels are made fresh, hot and delicious."
  • "Flavorful & well textured bagels."
  • "The bagels are amazing."

Cons:

  • "These bagels were just bland."
  • "Bagels weren't great."
  • "Bagel wasn't that good."
  • "The bagels are sometimes hard."
  • "Other bagel was an everything bagel that was over cooked and hard."
  • "The bagels are small and they put almost no cream cheese on the bagels."
  • "This place used to be the best... there’s minimal seasoning on it looks and taste like a plain bagel."

Service

Pros:

  • "The staff is incredibly nice."
  • "The staff was very friendly and I didn't feel pressured to order right away."
  • "Alba from Tarrytown branch has been so helpful each time we come in."
  • "Staff very friendly."
  • "Service was so efficient."
  • "The staff is professional, courteous, and very efficient!"
  • "All employees very customer oriented- polite, efficient, smiling. A+++"

Cons:

  • "The person taking your order isn't actually attentive and paying attention."
  • "They really need to figure it out here. Always getting my orders wrong."
  • "I have ordered many times online and roughly half of the orders have something missing, mixed up, burnt etc."
  • "The service is very slow. 2pm, 4 customers in line, 5 employees. Nobody is serviced."
  • "Service was sooo bad. The guy who took the order was extremely rude and not patient."
  • "I stood on line and waited 6 minutes while the crew was chatting with one other."
  • "The service was terrible, there were flies everywhere."

Price

Pros:

  • "I love bagels, and this place delivers an incredible bagel at a solid price."
  • "Great bagels, great portions and good server."
  • "Best bagels in Westchester by far."

Cons:

  • "I was a little disappointed though that my two bagels and coffee were $10."
  • "Bagel is 1.10 then they charge to toast it like 75 cents then cream cheese is 1.35."
  • "Be cautious of their prices! I got the lox bagel. It was good... but it cost me almost 16 dollars for that one bagel!!"
  • "Finally ordered a bagel toasted with peanut butter, super simple order came out to almost $4, Jesus, ok."
  • "I have been coming here for YEARS. My order, a bagel with bacon and egg, used to cost around $5. I went today and it cost me basically $8."
  • "Ridiculous price for the lack of product."
  • "Not only is this place extremely over priced. But several times I have made a cold salad purchase and the salad has been spoiled #rotten."

Cleanliness

Pros:

  • "The premises are clean, with tables to eat in if you don't want to take out."
  • "The overall atmosphere is very comforting."

Cons:

  • "The people preparing food need to have something covering their hair (both facial and head). It’s unsanitary."
  • "Half way through bagel I smelled a little vinegar then I realized the cream cheese was just getting sour."
  • "It seems they don’t clean their cutting boards or knives because I got a sausage egg and cheese that tasted like it was made on top of a pile of salmon."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.