H&H Bagels Reviews Summary

Bagel Quality

Pros:

• "Delicious bagels and cream cheese! I love how fresh and yummy all their bagels are."
• "The bagel bread itself was some of the best I’ve had."
• "Good bagels. Outstanding cream cheese, including the vegan cream cheese."
• "These bagels are amazing. I’ve had bagels all over the country and I think H&H makes the best."
• "Nothing like a Bagel hot out the oven."
• "Delishious bagels, everything fresh."
• "The black and white cookies at checkout were so delicious."

Cons:

• "But the bagel itself tasted a day old even though I was there early in the day."
• "One of the worst bagels I've ever eaten. Small, soggy, disgusting."
• "The bagels taste hard, dense and stale."
• "The bagel was too thick and Chewy."
• "The bagel itself tastes like and has the texture of a stale day old bagel."
• "Bagels are not good, stale tasting, and have a massive hole so you’re not getting a lot of bagel."
• "Very disappointed with dry texture & flavor of bagels. Definitely not the H&H original bagel recipe."

Service

Pros:

• "Exceptional help w food for my dad’s burial. 30 everything bagels with nova lox and cream cheese in separate bags with napkins."
• "The staff were so busy but had everything organized very well."
• "The staff was very friendly and patient. Overall a great experience."
• "A great bagel spot! Be sure to say hi to sweet Thomas who has always been so kind and welcoming to our family as we settled into the neighborhood!"
• "The workers were nice 😊."
• "Alexis is an incredible employee. I made a big error and she helped. She was so great and so kind."
• "I love this place not just because the bagels are amazing but because the staff are wonderful too."

Cons:

• "They almost always get your order wrong the first time."
• "The worst service in Manhattan. They had a C HEALTH RATING."
• "The customer service is the worse I’ve ever experienced."
• "The service is incredibly slow and the bagels are super expensive! I paid $7.50 for a basic breakfast egg sandwich."
• "Too many times they have screwed up my order."
• "Service is below average for a bagel shop."
• "The customer service was TERRIBLE."

Price

Pros:

• "I usually get dozen bagels and get 1 free."
• "H&H Bagels gave out free bagels, celebrating the premier of Dead City."
• "The lox sandwich was pretty expensive, but it comes with a decent amount of fish so it's only moderately overpriced and worth the occasional splurge."

Cons:

• "Prices were a bit higher than I expected but it's New York I guess haha 😂 Still worth it in my mind."
• "Everything seems a tad overpriced for what you get, but it's tasty and fresh."
• "The prices for anything on the bagel (below average!) are insanely high. Huge ripoff!"
• "Good quality, but way overpriced for what it is."
• "The menu shows reasonably priced bagels, 3.5$ to 4.5$, but we ordered bagels with cream cheese and salmon, the price was 17$!"
• "14 dollars for nova sandwich to much money but the taste is well worth it."
• "They are the most expensive around at $1.90 a piece."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "Nice spot with a vibrant setting."
• "Cute place, there's a nice area for sitting, I got a bagel with cream cheese and vegetables it was fresh and good just what I wanted."
• "Good place to sit and meet for informal meetings."
• "Came in on a Sunday afternoon - busy but not overly populated. Plenty of casual seating."
• "Order eggs with your bagel anytime of the day at this area favorite. Lots of seating available inside. It appears to have been recently renovated with well done modern decor."
• "The ship environment is pretty cool, clean and well decorated."
• "Moynihan Train Station is very clean with a few food choices for breakfast, lunch and dinner."

Cons:

• "Since opening in 2017 it's steadily fallen into disrepair and the eating area is dirty."
• "Unfortunately there is no place to sit down and eat."
• "This place seems to be trying to make it as inhospitable as possible to dine in."
• "The service and atmosphere was good too."