Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "This place has one of the best pizzas I have ever eaten in the USA."
• "The tomato sauce is made in-house and adds amazing taste to the perfectly crunchy and chewy crust."
• "The pizza was great and it wasn’t floppy, it was a good solid flat bread."
• "The wings were so delicious."
• "Excellent pizza with fresh delicious toppings."
• "Food is excellent. Meatballs are homemade and amazing."
• "The pizza was gorgeous and delicious."

Cons:

• "I basically paid $25 for some cheesy bread in a Large pizza box."
• "First time going and found the pizza's crust to be equivalent to cardboard...dry and brittle."
• "The pizza was ok needed a lil more flavor for me!"
• "The pizza says its 'Well Done' which I took to mean well prepared. Wrong they burnt the crust."
• "Our eggplant pizza was tasteless."
• "The square speciality pizzas come out burnt. I don't mean well done, I mean parts are black."
• "The famed pizza was very doughy and a bit underdone."

Service

Pros:

• "Thanks for the kind service Marty and staff."
• "The service is personable and friendly."
• "Awesome service."
• "Service was excellent, Dawn was very helpful with the menu explaining details on each dish."
• "The service was also outstanding."
• "The servers and bartenders have all been friendly and helpful."
• "Service is always great and friendly."

Cons:

• "They said they had curbside pickup but no one ever came out so I ended up going in."
• "I would have easily given 5 stars except we had poor service from a server who very clearly doesn't like her job, which I disclosed to management."
• "Had a terrible experience with the women doing take out."
• "We tried calling them to return the pizza, couldn’t find the server for a good 10 mins."
• "The servers are generally not great; tonight ours kept touching her hair and face, and talking with the bartender...ugh"
• "Our waitress was a tad slow."
• "Take out service is awful. So slow and no one seemed to care."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "A reliable and fun place for after work."
• "The atmosphere is awesome! The small outside portion of the restaurant is cozy and the inside gives you the feel of a clean sports dive bar."
• "Love Love Love this place. It’s a hidden treasure. Best Pizza."
• "The atmosphere is so fun and so great."
• "Great atmosphere and will definitely be back."
• "The atmosphere is inviting with many tv's to watch any event as well as great celebrity photos to admire!"
• "Great little place with a warm atmosphere."

Cons:

• "It's a little pricey here, but they have plenty of TVs and an outside area."
• "You will spend a lot here though as beer and drinks add up fast so once you have had a few beers and a pizza you're shelling out north of 50 dollars."
• "The restaurant is also really crammed during busy hours, the seating is all tightly squeezed together."
• "Unfortunately as time passed their customer service and food prep declined quickly."
• "The environment was not good at all. It was like you were in the halls of a high school."
• "It's a bit noisy but the pizza was excellent."
• "Bad experience... The environment was not good at all."

Value

Pros:

• "Also, the food and drinks are reasonably priced."
• "Two pizzas, two orders of wings, two glasses of sangria, two beers, iced tea, all for under a hundred bucks was great."
• "It's a reasonable place to go I won't break the bank."
• "Reasonably priced food is quality."
• "Great selection of local beers on tap."
• "Pizza is good parking is great plenty of room."
• "Their wings and pizza are higher quality than the same options offered at the local shops."

Cons:

• "Also, for those 2 pies it was $47!! Insane"
• "The food is good but pricey for pizza+."
• "We just had 3 pizzas delivered for $96 and all 3 were so soggy we had to toss them."
• "Too expensive and not enough selections to choose from."
• "I did find the fountain drinks to be high at $3.29 before taxes, but not enough to keep me from coming back."
• "Nothing tasted fresh and way overpriced."
• "Last Wed I found out that they no longer have the pizza special ($10 large pie). Because we are both on disability we really can't afford their regular prices."