John's of Arthur Ave. Reviews Summary

Category: Pizza restaurant

Address: 115 Seventh St, Milford, PA 18337, USA

Phone: +15704096996

Rating: 4.4
based on 126 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Best pizza around.....get red non hot peppers and sausage and if you like black olives...it rocks!"
  • "Fantastic staff, wonderful sauce and breads you will NOT be sorry."
  • "The best Calzone and some of the best pizza we’ve ever had!! So cheesy and soft and perfect flavor combos."
  • "You can tell right away that they use QUALITY ingredients and do not cut corners."
  • "The pizzas are pure artwork and I highly recommend a slice of the Motown Detroit pizza."
  • "The best meatballs ever, sorry grandma!"
  • "The pizza was good, mostly due to the cheese. The mozzarella was excellent."

Cons:

  • "Their pizzas aren't seasoned very well, and that's what I'm most familiar with."
  • "The ham was the cheapest Ham money can buy looked like spiced ham."
  • "Gluten free pizza crust was NOT good. It was bland, dry & like a big GF cracker with pizza toppings."
  • "However, their actual Sicilian looks and tastes like frozen supermarket pizza."
  • "The spinach calzone, they used frozen chopped spinach and it was horrible!!"
  • "The Sicilian Pizza was completely burnt."
  • "The pizza was horrible and the Italian combo sub only had 1 piece of ham, 1 piece of salami, & 2 pieces of provolone."

Service

Pros:

  • "The staff was very, very friendly and welcoming."
  • "Exemplary staff, very friendly laid back atmosphere."
  • "Sam at the front counter is super personable and great at suggestions."
  • "The employees are ALWAYS friendly & the delivery people ALWAYS nice!!"
  • "Waitresses are very friendly and accommodating."
  • "Served by Jessie, who was very friendly and attentive."
  • "The staff provide the best customer service so I will always come here to eat!!"

Cons:

  • "Super friendly staff besides one rude younger counter girl."
  • "I was disappointed in the service and how I was charged."
  • "Ordered a pizza was told the price and to pickup in 35 minutes. Got there and they didn't have my order."
  • "We were asked several times 'Oh you want it for here?!' and were made to feel like we were an inconvenience."
  • "Order chicken parmesan I got shrimp parmesan... very poor waitressing water glasses went empty."
  • "The person on the phone and the person who took our credit card were both curt and unfriendly."
  • "I felt like we were bothering the staff."

Price

Pros:

  • "They also have weekly specials to get pies at a real reasonable price. I recommend using these!"
  • "The everyday special was a good price."
  • "Mon & Tues cheese pizza for $9. Makes it real easy to eat pizza twice a week."
  • "Today we ordered a family special... all for like $40.00!"
  • "The 21.99 deal is amazing, love it every time."

Cons:

  • "Not worth the $24 I paid."
  • "If you're gonna charge $5/slice for the Detroit, it is delusional to charge $4 for that Sicilian slice."
  • "$46 for a 3 topping pie? What on earth!? We are in MILFORD PA!!!!"
  • "On top of being overpriced, it is about 800 degrees inside this restaurant."
  • "They charged me $5 per plain slice no toppings."
  • "Service is down, prices are up...very sad."
  • "Way overpriced for woods of PA and don't bother with the broccoli rabe -- most bitter tasting, overcooked mess ever."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "The fireplace gives it a warm cozy atmosphere, we love going here!"
  • "The gas fireplace was cozy too."
  • "The atmosphere inside is definitely nice for your typical pizza place."
  • "Nice outdoor dining area."
  • "Great place to dine in or outside under the trees' shade."

Cons:

  • "My only complaint is how hot it was in the restaurant due to the ovens- making it an ideal takeout/delivery place but not good for sit-in in hot weather."
  • "Feels like a city park instead of a fabulous eatery."
  • "They no longer offer the option to dine in house with waitress service."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.