"The rice balls are supper delicious and the pizza was great."
"Everything tasted so fresh and delicious."
"Creamy Polenta was delicious."
"The food was great and I'm from Brooklyn."
Cons:
"Missing the chicken in the pasta, missing drinks, the pasta is too dry."
"I don’t trust they take gluten allergy seriously."
"The eggplant parm tasted like it came from a high school cafeteria."
"The pizza wasn't terrible exactly, but despite having a brick oven there was no real flavor to the dough."
"Really poor service, food on pictures looks delicious unfortunately it is not!"
"I ordered the seafood fra diavolo, the pasta was way overcooked and very light on the seafood."
"The veal was terrible!! Did not eat at all."
Service
Pros:
"Consistent quality and very friendly/prompt service."
"I specially appreciated for the lady who served us with that patient, polite manner."
"Our server Kaylee was warm, cheerful and professional."
"The service was impeccable and even with the restaurant being very busy on a Friday evening we were seated immediately without a reservation."
"Host and service staff, kitchen too... Top notch!"
"The service is really great and attentive."
"Our server, Valerie was outstanding!"
Cons:
"Absolutely horrible service from Paul the person assigning seats for the restaurant."
"Our waiter was slow at each phase of the meal, and brought out the wrong item."
"The service was absolutely terrible!"
"She was a serious disappointment!!! :(( She had a terrible attitude and it was unbelievable how she noisily put the dishes on the table, ignored our queries, and replied in all hostility, if at all she did!"
"Staff wasn't friendly, and very rude."
"Service wise, we were placed in a back room with a few other people, there we seemed to be forgotten about a bit."
"Bar tender named Mike, bald tall gentlemen was very rude throughout dinner."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"Have been enjoying this restaurant since it opened at least 20 years ago. Remodeled a couple of years ago and it is just beautiful."
"They offer a more intimate personal dining experience."
"Live music in the bar area."
"The food and ambience of the restaurant was fantastic."
"A calm atmosphere with great lighting and decor."
"The interior is polished and refined."
"Clean. Comfortable atmosphere."
Cons:
"Just be aware it is a little pricey, and it's popular enough for good reasons that there can be waits, especially since Covid."
"What a disappointment my feet froze waitress showed occasional my dish was cold."
"The only real thing to be careful of here is the parking at this location can be a bit tricky."
"The young man who brought us to our table was, subjectively, not suited for the hospitality industry."
"There were flies in the restaurant near our table."
"The lights were dim so it was difficult to see but aside from the tables and obvious spots you could see the place was kinda dirty."
"Not organized. Squeezed 6+2 ppl in a booth seat that fits 6 only while the 8 ppl table left available for 5 other guests."
Value
Pros:
"Great prices."
"Pricing is a bit high but when it comes to what you're getting? It's a steal."
"The food was nice and the price was pretty affordable!"
"Food is delicious and reasonably priced."
"The price is fair to the size and portion for meals."
"The service was wonderful & ambiance is always lovely."
"Good big portions, worth price."
Cons:
"And very expensive."
"It's more stars when you can actually patronize the place without being lied to."
"Just be aware it is a little pricey."
"But now for two 12 inch pizzas, 2 sodas and a salad it was almost $50."
"The only downside is the price; but if you aren’t buying or for a fancier celebration this is the place to go when you’re in the area."
"A tad bit expensive though compared to other similar places."
"The kid meals are overpriced for Pesketti and other options."
Accessibility
Pros:
"There’s tons of sittings here and also has parking lot, parking was easy."
"If you are shopping at Woodbury Common Mall I recommend you visit it."
"It's become a destination for us. Woodberry Commons shopping and an obligated stop at Cosimo's."
"Cosimo's is a very nice Italian resto that located not too far from Woodsbury Factory Outlet."
"They put us in the wine room which was spacious and private, great room!"
"We had a dedicated server for our party, she was attentive, professional, helpful and fun!"
"Cosimos is a nice night out."
Cons:
"The only negative was the size of the tables. Too small for all the dishes and glasses."
"Only gripe is their party room is down a flight of stairs in first level with no handicapped access."
"If you want space between people, i suggest avoiding this place since it can get really busy, and the tables are right on top of each other."
"Not a lot of Italian places in the area... we ordered a personal broccoli pie and it had about 12 whole garlic cloves hidden inside the pizza."
"The way they don't split a check by party is the reason it gets a 3 star instead of a 5."
"Just left Cosimo's thanks for forgetting about us outside. We asked to eat outside and no one even took a drink order."
"Not a very friendly, welcoming, accommodating place."