Bagels & Co Reviews Summary

Bagel Quality

Pros:

• "The best bagels and the best homemade cream cheeses in NYC."
• "You Can never go wrong with that nova lox bagel with toppings!"
• "Great bagels including really healthy and delicious fully whole wheat bagels and whole wheat everything Bagels."
• "Best Bagel I have ever had, definitely on the savory side, but worth it!"
• "Delicious bagels. I’m a bagel girl. A bagel connoisseur of sorts."
• "I had a lox everything bagel and wow, It was everything I hoped for!"
• "These are giant delicious fresh bagels and the cream cheese is fantastic."

Cons:

• "The bagels were rock hard."
• "It wasn't a great bagel either, the people behind don't communicate and there simply aren't any decent bagel places in the area, including this one."
• "Worst breakfast ever. Absolutely tasteless, like eating cardboard."
• "First of all the bagel was terrible and flavorless and the texture was like biting into cardboard."
• "Bagels are mediocre."
• "Over priced gluten free bagels."
• "Meh. Huge doughy bagel and bialy. What happened to normal sized bagels and bialys?"

Service

Pros:

• "The staff moves quick so place your order, get to the front to pay, and then wait for your food to be ready."
• "I thought the service was polite and quick (especially useful with hungry kids) and the food was very good as well."
• "Quick service, good food, friendly staff and somewhat decent (albeit drip) coffee."
• "Also the guy who helped me was friendly and I appreciated his joking conversation with a new customer."
• "Service was friendly and the food was just right."
• "Their employees are polite and helpful and followed our instructions."
• "The customer was quick, efficient and attentive!"

Cons:

• "They ask what you want, and then like clockwork they turn away from you while you’re trying to explain the particulars of your order, missing the details of what you want."
• "Poor service but good bagels."
• "The customer service is lacking."
• "Service was pretty slow considering I ordered immediately and it took over 5 minutes to get my order."
• "The guy at the cashier is incredible rude."
• "Service is less great."
• "Service is gruff and leaves a lot to be desired."

Price

Pros:

• "Prices are pretty high for what you're getting, but definitely a nice treat!"
• "Great value for money... would eat here more days a week if it was closer!!!"
• "Also for their location, the prices here are fair."
• "Great hand-rolled bagels for $1.25."
• "I get a 10% senior discount. Every little savings helps as well."
• "Best bagel.shop in Manhattan. Was last there in 2015 and the owner remembered me. Prices are still the same as 2015."
• "A little hole in the wall, but great bagels, and decent prices."

Cons:

• "My real issue is with the prices, which just seem to keep going up."
• "They are quite pricey though, considering its a loaf of bread with cream cheese and bits of salmon."
• "Decent neighborhood place, albeit pretty pricy."
• "Prices high for mostly mayo spreads."
• "Prices were high compared to other kosher bagels/cafe's in NYC."
• "They often get right out angry for very simple requests."
• "A $3 bagel costed me $9.31 before tip."