Mimmo's Brick Oven Pizza & Trattoria | Best Pizza Near Me Staten Island Reviews Summary

Service

Pros:

• "Diego our waiter was absolutely amazing!!!"
• "Our waiter, Jacob was equally awesome!"
• "The service was OUTSTANDING!"
• "The customer service is spot on."
• "The service is great and the staff are very sweet, welcoming and give the best service."
• "The staff were great."
• "The servers are so sweet and attentive."

Cons:

• "The waiter was nice and apologetic, but an hour was uncalled for."
• "We may not return."
• "This attitude was the worst attitude I’ve ever seen in a restaurant."
• "The service and take out are horrendous!"
• "To add injury to insult, our server took his revenge on us by charging the full bogo higher price of the dish we never received."
• "Our dinner was ruined by a rude server who made a mistake on an order and attempted to place the blame on us."
• "I always call the store but you’re never there when I would call and I will get your son Ralph, which I don’t think he even cared."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The food was amazing! So delicious."
• "The penne ala vodka was creamy and gone in seconds!!"
• "The Cheesesteak pinwheel and Cookie pinwheel are absolutely phenomenal."
• "The chicken was tender the mozzarella was fresh and the sauce was to die for."
• "BBQ chicken slice is on point."
• "Their pizza is delicious as well as their other rolls and specialties."
• "Everything was made so well and the shrimp was cooked to perfection."

Cons:

• "The food was ok, but a bit overpriced for the amount you received."
• "The pie was too tough, like it was stale."
• "The plain 🍕 didn't taste like anything."
• "It was pure garbage I vomited. Worst food ever."
• "Horrible food."
• "But the food quality was terrible because it was ice cold."
• "The food is subpar at best."

Price and Value

Pros:

• "For what we paid we got more than we could ask for!!"
• "All of this food (plus a glass of wine & salad) was very reasonably priced."
• "The price for the packages were very reasonable."
• "DELICIOUS FOOD and priced right!"
• "The b1g1 entree deal is definitely worth it because you get enough to fill you up."
• "The entree deal Mimmo's offer on dine in is pretty good."
• "Such a nice family business. Reasonable prices - you have to try this place."

Cons:

• "I use to buy from them a lot and i been seeing the price go from 6.50 for a chicken roll to about 12 dollars."
• "When you charge some one 3 times the price for a chickenroll or w.e it is then some thing is up."
• "They like to charge more or add more money to your bill."
• "Everywhere it says $14.70 for a regular cheese pie but he charged me $16."
• "However, I was annoyed that upon examining receipt when I got home they had added a percentage for using a credit card."
• "Be aware that if you're paying with a credit card you will be assessed an additional 4% for using a credit card as payment."
• "We were charged $4 extra for the fresh mozzarella on the margherita 🍕, which also had no basil."

Ambience and Space

Pros:

• "The room was spacious for the 30 guests I had and I know they can host even more!"
• "Great atmosphere. If I had 3 thumbs I give it 3 thumbs up."
• "Love the atmosphere!"
• "The restaurant itself was the perfect space that I needed it was comfortable and beautiful."
• "It looks like the restaurant was recently renovate and is very Tuscan."
• "Their dining room is also amazing it looks beautiful."
• "This place is a hidden gem."

Cons:

• "Not very big and very plain inside."
• "I wish they would drop the blinds on the large front windows so you don't have to stare into the parking lot while you're eating... kind of puts a damper on the ambience."
• "Parking is for the strong."
• "No signs for which pizza is which!"
• "The brick oven was not on."
• "The Italian bread for the hero was not Real italian Bread I think it was Albanian bread. It was horrible."
• "The pizza is like it came from Jersey."