"Tried the half eggplant and half paulie's pie which was meatball and sausage with hot peppers. It was delicious."
"The pizza is fantastic and the wings are great, too."
"Classic Italian salad and cheesecake were also very very good!"
"The garlic knots were perfect, reminded me of pizzerias in Brooklyn from my childhood."
"They have great wines, sangria, and cocktails too."
"Pizza and people were very tasty & friendly. Ill defiantly stop back when I'm in the area!"
"The pizza was absolutely delicious!!!!"
Cons:
"If you're going to overcharge for your pizza... you should give quality pizza that is not burnt."
"the crust was completely burnt, oily, chicken was bad"
"The total was over $100. The taste was not worth the money. Wings where super dry. Not edible."
"What a poor execution of pizza making. The dough is burnt in places, huge strips of subpar prosciutto and globs of tomato sauce."
"The wings had absolutely zero flavor. They were very tough and barely had any caramelized onions."
"The Margarita pizza was average, not even the coal fired taste could make the cheap cheese they use and bland sauce work."
"The pizza was extremely salty to the extent that we cannot even finish one slice."
Service
Pros:
"Our waitress Denise, was amazing! She took care of us twice so far."
"Service was pretty good. They work hard because they have to. They're all polite and welcoming."
"Staff and management take very good care of customers, especially if you're a repeat customer."
"The Anthony's Coal Fired Team in Edison goes above and beyond to treat their customers like family."
"Our attendant was just that, attentive. Denise made us feel at home and important."
"Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza was amazing, the service was fantastic, they made you feel welcome and like family."
"The bartender Hailey greeted us and served us drinks within a few mins of us sitting down."
Cons:
"The night shift suck at service."
"This was worst service I’ve every experience in my life."
"Service was okay but not great, waiter seemed uninterested and preoccupied."
"Service was a bit slow. We had to look for our server quite a bit."
"The waitress just never put it in."
"The server did her job ok, her clothes where dirty and little slow."
"Took over an hour and a half to get served food, the server was just horrible."
Ambiance
Pros:
"The experience at Anthony's was outstanding tonight! From the time we walked into the restaurant the ambiance was exquisitely radiant with a calm and friendly atmosphere."
"Loved the ambience."
"But what caught my attention was the décor of the restaurant. The ambiance was warm and inviting, with a cozy, rustic vibe that made me feel right at home."
"By the way, the atmosphere, makes you feel comfortable and at ease."
"the atmosphere was good and the restaurant has a nice decor."
"Atmosphere was very kid friendly."
"The music is wonderful, very eclectic. Love the pictures on the wall."
Cons:
"They need to adjust the AC as it was somewhat cold in the restaurant."
"Establishment was nice, but loud. Like so noisy you could barely carry on a conversation."
"It was so noisy I could hardly hear the person sitting next to me."
"The restaurant is a mess. I slid on a puddle on the way to my table."
"First impression was not good. I was given a dirty menu which was an immediate disappointment because it shows the lack of detail given by waitstaff!"
"The place is very casual."
"Lousy pizza on plastic plates on a sticky table on a dirty floor."
Value
Pros:
"Happy Hour specials and daily specials make this place lace a hidden gem."
"They also have good happy hour prices on weekdays."
"The best deal is Wednesday's Meatballs & Martinis for $5 Martinis from 5pm to close."
"Price was fair $10 and the food was good."
"Priced fairly and portioned well."
"Pizza is delicious. The smallest size pie was enough to split between two people."
"Wisely, the menu isn't extensive, choosing to execute a narrower range of choices well, with a standout wing offering and decent meatballs."
Cons:
"Beware some expensive drafts at $9.50 each. I didn't see a price posted anywhere. Pizza is also a bit pricey."
"for having spent close to $40 for a large pizza with 1 topping + 10 wings"
"It's not the cheapest place so be prepared to pay up"
"Overall, it was expensive. For 2 pizzas and a drink we had to pay around $70."
"It's a pretty pricey place for pizza."
"Very expensive food for barely average food. Burnt crust Pizza seems to be standard."