Sunset Diner Reviews Summary

Category: Diner New York

Address: 593 Meeker Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222, USA

Phone: +17183492777

Rating: 4.0
based on 131 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "The waitress was super nice and accommodating!"
  • "The waiter was attentive and polite (but busy and not overly chatty... which was welcomed)."
  • "Staff is always friendly and attentive."
  • "Staff was friendly and attentive with all the customers."
  • "Good service and friendly staff."
  • "The service was perfect from the time I walked in the door. Food came out fast, and it was delicious."
  • "Staff is always friendly and welcoming, no matter what time of day or night!"

Cons:

  • "I wish I could give them a 0. They were extremely rude, they failed to acknowledge my party enter their establishment."
  • "Complete rude owner hangs up on me because he is busy after telling my wife order is out."
  • "The cook was arguing with the waiter very unprofessional."
  • "The worst diner I’ve ever been to. Server and who I think was the managers attitudes were disgusting."
  • "The staff was extremely rude."
  • "The waiter there was very rude and disrespectful."
  • "Horrible service. Our waiter Winston was very impatient, obnoxious and RUDE!"

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Food is always fresh and delicious."
  • "Fresh tasty eggs, potatoes and bacon were tasty and prepared exactly as we asked."
  • "The food was exactly what I needed, and the portions were great."
  • "The absolute best breakfast food ever! I crave it everyday."
  • "I did, however, appreciate the care they took with their food preparation."
  • "Fair prices and good breakfast diner food."
  • "The food is well done classic diner style food with 1,384 options on the menu."

Cons:

  • "Although it's great that this place is 24-hours the food is not very good."
  • "I decided to try Sunset Diner and got one of the worst turkey dinners I have ever had for over $20."
  • "Food was waaaay over priced, marginally prepared and then they charged me a $4 surcharge on my $85 bill cause l used a credit card."
  • "The burger tasted like a school lunch burger, the fries that came with it were inedible and soggy."
  • "Food is bland, service is poor and dysfunctional."
  • "Absolutely terrible, bread on my burger was old and stale."
  • "AVOID AT ALL COST. Their food is terrible to begin with."

Cleanliness

Pros:

  • "The dining room is always kept fairly clean."
  • "Neighborhood diner with good food, satisfying portions, clean place with comfortable local ambience, and excellent service."
  • "Very cozy old school diner. Food was great. Service was fast. Atmosphere was cool."

Cons:

  • "If I could rate this restaurant a zero I would. Right after our food was brought out, a baby roach crawled across our table."
  • "The bathrooms really kept you on your toes- washing your hands without trying to actually touch the handles because they looked gross."
  • "It was also a dirty, highly don’t recommend."
  • "I found a hair in the omlette here/was disgusted and didn't even want to talk to a waitress."

Delivery & Takeout

Pros:

  • "The take out order was good."
  • "Sunset Diner is amazing. Delivery is on point and if you eat in, you are in luck."
  • "Delivery was quick."
  • "Ordered from them via Seamless a few months ago. The seamless driver brought only half the order by mistake and the restaurant drove the other half to me personally - in a snowstorm!"
  • "Ordered delivery from here on New Year’s Day. It was the perfect hangover food."

Cons:

  • "worst delivery experience in my life."
  • "I ordered from here and it took the delivery guy over an hour after he left the restaurant to get me my food."
  • "This was such a disappointment. I Placed an order through seamless which gave me an eta between 7:20-7:30 p.m delivery time. At 7:50 I called the restaurant and they told me the delivery guy would be there 'any minute'."
  • "Placed an order through Delivery for pickup. Got the confirmation text. Get there to have the guy rudely tell me he canceled my order."
  • "Sorry but I have to be completely honest and say they have lost there touch with delivery service, orders are incorrect."
  • "This place was HORRENDOUS! I ordered delivery from them on my Grubhub account and after over an hour of waiting outside for the delivery."

Pricing

Pros:

  • "Good inexpensive food."
  • "If you look for an authentic Diner experience with reasonable pricing Sunset is your place."
  • "The food was reasonably priced and the structure of the restaurant made it so customers were conversing with separate groups."
  • "Everything is priced reasonably."
  • "Price was to be expected for 5 people ($100)."

Cons:

  • "Order total was $54 for a burger, wrap, potato skins and and soda, that alone is outrageous."
  • "The 3 star rating is because it could be a lot cheaper considering the quality of the ingredients."
  • "Food was waaaay over priced, marginally prepared and then they charged me a $4 surcharge on my $85 bill cause l used a credit card."
  • "Very overpriced and not worth it at all, I don’t even be doing these reviews honestly."
  • "The meat loaf was 24$ with tax. That's a slab of ground beef with seasoning, which was average at best."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.