Pizza Barn Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Pizza was delicious and cheesy just the way my daughter and I love!"
• "THIS PIZZA WAS THE BEST PIZZA I HAD BY FAR."
• "The pizza was cooked perfectly with the crust has lightly crunch to it with cheese dripping off the slice."
• "The absolute best pizza I've ever tasted, their sauce is delicious!!"
• "The big slice pizza they are known for was absolutely delicious."
• "Crust has an amazing crunch texture. Sauce is not too sweet, not too salty it's just right! Cheese is Fresh!!"
• "The pizza tasted amazing and staff was very friendly!"

Cons:

• "Pizza was okay, ours needed more red sauce, we had spots that had just cheese."
• "The food lacks flavor and it's a hard pass for me I would not suggest it."
• "The cheese was bland and the sauce had no discernable flavor."
• "Wasn't bad but the pizza didn't have the flavor I was looking for."
• "The slice had no taste. The cheese was chewy, crust soft."
• "Pizza crust like cardboard, sauce tastes like tin cans."
• "The worst pizza I have ever had in New York it tasted like digiornos."

Service

Pros:

• "Great ingredients, great service, and an owner who cares about the product."
• "The staff there were very nice and friendly."
• "Service was exceptional, fast, friendly and on point."
• "The servers kept up friendly conversations and had such great energy."
• "The staff at Pizza Barn are friendly, attentive, and always ready to make your dining experience exceptional."
• "Excellent customer service! Very friendly staff especially the waitress."
• "Staff was very welcoming and attentive."

Cons:

• "Customer service was rude and extremely disrespectful to children as well."
• "A employee sat us down and another employee came from the kitchen and yelled at us saying we can’t sit on that table."
• "Not the friendliest sevice enviornment."
• "Waitress had an attitude tho but that is a one-off occurrence."
• "The owner was extremely unprofessional calling out a misunderstanding in front of the customers."
• "I usually don’t write reviews, but the owner is very rude."
• "The owner is very rude He's also very rude to his own staff I watched him talk to his female staff member in a very demeaning way."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "Pizza Barn is a true gem in the city of Yonkers, NY."
• "These super slices are delicious and photogenic too!"
• "Very cool experience!"
• "It really does look like a barn inside, and to be a pizza place, it just blows your mind."
• "Coming here you notice right away that the atmosphere is very cool, the ambiance is really modern and the service is amazing."
• "From the outside it looks like a potential hole in the wall pizza spot (which are usually the best) but when you walk in its tiny yet warm, *clean* and welcoming."
• "The owner Angelo came over and was very welcoming and educated us on the history of Pizza Barn."

Cons:

• "The food was WONDERFUL but not a good sit down restaurant experience."
• "Small establishments more for the takeout but we drove from Connecticut so we ended up eating outside as the inside was very full and crowded."
• "It was such a small, cramped place."
• "We waited an hour outside because they only have 5 or 6 tables inside."
• "The venue is small and there might be a wait line outside to even place an order."
• "The dining area is extremely small, but clean."
• "Outdoor seating includes 3 tables with 4 to 5 seats."

Value

Pros:

• "Prices are pretty fair as well (they've increased a bit since they started doing the super slice but still very reasonable!)."
• "One super slice gives you 14 slices once it's cut and for a cheese pizza it was $14."
• "Great pizza at a pretty good price."
• "It was also quite inexpensive so that was good."
• "The pricing is fair for the size."
• "Price was amazing and tasted great."
• "It’s a very cheap and reasonable price for the entire meal."

Cons:

• "Personally, the food is overpriced; as the regular slice seems smaller than average."
• "But... here comes the BUT: the slice is big and that's very exciting but they are charging crazy amounts of money for an enlarged slice or a pie shaped like a slice."
• "Although it was good, it was extremely expensive for what it is. This one slice cost me $7."
• "Way overpriced as well."
• "Sorry super overpriced the Supreme slice is not even bigger than a large pie and it's $45."
• "It is overpriced and very gimmicky."
• "The only thing that needs to change is the surcharge on credit cards."

Convenience

Pros:

• "During the week and lunch time there's no wait."
• "They have a huge box for the huge slice to go."
• "There is free parking available across the street next to the park which is a huge plus in New York!"
• "This new location is a game-changer – it's incredibly spacious, with ample parking."
• "Private parking lot for customers."
• "They now have a parking lot, more seats (meaning more space), and restrooms!"
• "Parking can be tricky but we parked at the park right across the street."

Cons:

• "If you're planning to go on weekends you may get a 2-3 hours wait."
• "Parking might be a problem but if u don't mind a short walk then you're ok."
• "I really needed to use the bathroom but there was none at the location and we had to walk several minutes to a nearby pharmacy which was extremely inconvenient."
• "There is no bathroom on the premises so you habe to use the portosans in the park, which are gross, or down the street at another business."
• "No restroom."
• "The 40 minute wait outside in the cold weather was disparaging."
• "Visiting family from Texas and drove 2 hours and paid tolls just to be greeted with a sign on the door that says 'closed for vacation'."