"The rustic double pepperoni pizza was good. The crust is crunchy and just the right amount of cheese and tomato sauce."
"The sauce is excellent - hands down was 2nd best sauce I have tasted."
"The pizza tastes very good and pure. It’s simple yet full of flavor."
"Phenomenal Margherita-style brick oven pizza!!!"
"Some of the best pizza we’ve ever had."
"All ingredients are freshly made and packed with flavor!"
"The pizza was light, with fresh ingredients and perfect proportions."
Cons:
"The experience overall was not worth the price."
"The pizza is a bit overpriced for the taste."
"The slice looked promising with large tomato pieces on top, but when it arrived it was disappointing."
"The white ricotta pesto was too mellow and lacked that kick."
"Pizza was good not amazing!"
"The pizza was bland."
"The pie didn’t have extra cheese and was mostly just pepperoni & sauce and to top it off it was overcooked."
Service
Pros:
"Excellent Italian restaurant with perfect service and great food for almost normal prices."
"The service was awesome and we really enjoyed the food."
"Our waiter was attentive and friendly."
"Service was excellent and prices were reasonable."
"Service was quick and attentive without being intrusive."
"The staff were friendly and accommodating of request."
"The staff was very friendly and helpful."
Cons:
"Took forever to get drinks, forgot the parmesan and pepper flakes, and just a general 'can't be bothered with you attitude'."
"The table service was fine, but the front of house service wasn’t great."
"Service here was disappointing, our waiter didn't pay us any mind and left to tell us he was going on break after never bringing any drinks to the table."
"The waitress was not really nice, just ok."
"Waiter was rude and the pizza was WAY overpriced."
"The wait staff kept forgetting items and not all at once."
"Service was mediocre at best and food well, it was a disappointment."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"Very cozy place to enjoy a pizza."
"The atmosphere is quaint and quite lovely."
"You get that old NYC nostalgia right away."
"Italian ambience in Little Italy style."
"Cozy, warm, inviting."
"The atmosphere is really nice."
"The atmosphere was delightful, with cozy seating and attentive staff."
Cons:
"The decor and atmosphere feels a bit dated also."
"Shame that when it's too busy you have to sit out in a plastic booth."
"We dined outside on the street. The chairs are hard and could be better."
"Only took a point off for the atmosphere because we ate outside and didn't get to enjoy the inside ambiance."
"Nothing terrible happened but the whole time there was a very bad vibe, you’re tired from walking all over the city and the staff asks to order 3 times before you look at the menu."
"The salad, it’s nothing special and drenched in dressing."
"The lack of digital payment options in 2023 was disappointing."
Payment and Pricing
Pros:
"CASH ONLY!!!"
"Food: delicious and reasonably priced. Atmosphere: iconic."
"Service was excellent and prices were reasonable."
"The cost was cheaper than most other places."
"The prices are affordable and the staff is very friendly and attentive with the customers."
"Prices are great for the quality you are getting."