NY Pizza Suprema Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Great pizza, lots to choose from."
• "The vegan pizza slices are the BEST in NYC."
• "The crust was the best I’ve ever had. It was light, crispy, yet pillowy soft."
• "All the slices were very good except for the eggplant."
• "Classic New York thin slice, perfect bruciato crunch but not dry, passed the fold test, fresh quality ingredients."
• "The sauce is fresh and savory. The cheese is excellent quality and perfectly dispersed and melted."
• "Freshest ingredients, Grande Mozzarella, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Incredible Napolitano Thin Crust Pie & delicious Feta Cheese."

Cons:

• "The first day we went the slice of pizza was missing yeast and the slice did not have any rise."
• "Sometimes the pizza is burnt and other times it comes out just right."
• "The second time both slices were burnt."
• "Unfortunately, they didn't have cheese when I arrived."
• "The pizza did not hold up to the 'fold' test."
• "The mushroom slice is more mushy than mouth watering."
• "Pizza did not have flavor."

Service

Pros:

• "Service is fast and it’s cheap."
• "Hard to find a seat sometimes but the line moves very quickly."
• "Service is good. And when we walked out, they said goodbye to us by name which was a nice touch!"
• "The service was pleasant and quick."
• "The cheers and appreciation from the staff when we added to the tip jar was genuine and fun."
• "The staff is friendly while also being super quick and efficient so everyone can get their food while it's hot."
• "The service was super fast and the cashier was fun and engaging."

Cons:

• "The mexican guy asking for our pizza orders is the rudest person I have encountered."
• "The service always feels a little chaotic."
• "None of the counter employees are personable, they are there for their money period."
• "The staff was not friendly and always in a rush."
• "Service very ordinary. Employees yelling at each other... I feel the vibe was negative and food just ok."
• "Staff is rude, no waitress service."
• "The ordering experience was one of the most aggressive ordering experiences I've had."

Price

Pros:

• "Bite into a whole range of awesome NY pizza at reasonable prices (~$5-7 USD per slice)."
• "Cash only. $5 for a hefty hot honey pizza."
• "The prices were reasonable."
• "Your dollar goes far at this pizza place."
• "The prices are also very reasonable."
• "Fairly priced, the regular slice for $4.50 is a good Midtown Deal."
• "Not even expensive for the quality: from $6 a slice."

Cons:

• "Little pricey but if you want to get ya pizza fix off the train this is the place to go."
• "A decent meal of 2 slices and a drink will set you back by around 13$ or so..."
• "Overhyped and overpriced..."
• "Paying $6.50 for a slice of pizza is INSANE."
• "$6 a slice of pepperoni is insane but what’s weirder is it’s worth it."
• "Really good pizza, but way over priced in my opinion."
• "It's crazy expensive for pizza $6-$8 per slice and $50 per pizza."

Location & Ambience

Pros:

• "This place has been around for a very long time and owned by the same family."
• "A perfect place to grab your first or last bite of pizza in NYC."
• "A few minutes from Penn Station. Open until midnight."
• "Area can get sketch at late night but the pizza is that good it’s still worth getting."
• "Perfect location for a quick slice of NYC pizza. Across the street from Penn Station and MSG."
• "This place is a 'must-go' when I visit NYC."
• "This place looks like it's been in the neighborhood for awhile, I mean that in a good way."

Cons:

• "Sadly 3 were already sold out. We came with a large vegan group and only the square veggie no cheese and the basic slice one were available."
• "They don't have big space and no parking."
• "The signs sometime are not placed with the corresponding pizza tho."
• "The atmosphere is great. It is clean which is hard to say for sit down pizza spots in New York."
• "The bathroom is absolutely tiny!! And that hallway is a nightmare!! Seriously! The layout sucks but the restaurant is amazing!!"
• "Seating is limited but what can you expect?"
• "They have lots of tables, but they are usually full."