"Attmosphere is awesome! I love old engineered buildings and they did and great job to restore and keep as much of the original design of the old brick mill building as possible."
"You can sit either in the shade or the sun."
"One of the best outdoor dining pubs in Newark."
"I love the retro factory/mill look and view over the creek."
"Atmosphere is quaint, welcoming, and not bias to an After Work round with the team, a pleasant date night with your partner, or a family get together of 24 adults/kids."
"Such a cool building, was an old factory and was refurbed to be a restaurant/bar/small banquet place."
"The atmosphere is fun and I love the rustic of the place."
Cons:
"Large dining but can get a little loud, the price you pay for being popular."
"A bit noisy inside even at lunch time but not overbearing."
"Noise is part of the issue associated with the above! Acoustics cannot be changed unless you destroy or cover up the original design of this wonderful building."
"I'm not big on the dark older bar scene."
"Some of the crowds can be more rowdy than others (weekends / happy hour) so depending on your company be sure to plan date/time accordingly."
"The atmosphere is blah!"
"Often loud and full of college kids though."
Service
Pros:
"Management was very helpful and flexible in making arrangements, and pricing was reasonable."
"It has an awesome staff, mouth watering food, and an assortment of drink options."
"Our server Laura was great, lively and very informative."
"Our waiter, Luke, was nice and kept checking on us during the meal to see if we needed anything."
"The staff is super friendly and helpful."
"The service there was excellent! The waitress was friendly and she checked on us multiple times."
"They were very helpful and professional."
Cons:
"Normally have a great experience here but tonight we had terrible service."
"Always wanted to try Timothy's, well last night we did, service was so slow, food was cold and tasteless."
"This situation was handled very unprofessionally."
"Absolute horrible customer service! I tried to report a STAPLE in my food and the female manager there would not tell me her name and dismissed herself after I told her how upset."
"The owner/s Alyssa Cavanaugh is My daughter, she lied about My order, she was deceiving about desert, and refused to speak with me personally via video conference."
"We were seated but never served."
"At 310p we decided to leave since the wait staff had not approached us yet nor even offered a glass of water."
Food Quality
Pros:
"Their spinach salad is my favorite and had a great cilantro dressing."
"Food tastes pretty good, but it has been becoming more and more inconsistent over the last several months."
"There is a great selection of draught beers."
"Great food, cooked exactly as we requested."
"The food was incredible!!!! I ordered the ribeye with sweet potato tots and broccoli and the sweet potato tots were some of the best I have ever had."
"Food was great as always. They consistently deliver great food."
"The food was great."
Cons:
"Upon finally receiving our food on the way out in boxes, my fries were burnt, most likely sat under the heat lamp entirely too long."
"The garlic fries were garlicky but alas had absolutely no salt."
"Got the Cowboy Wrap. Sounded good...it was not."
"The only thing i really enjoyed were the ribs and Buffalo chicken dip which were pretty nice but thats it."
"My only complaint is that we ordered the seafood nachos and about only 1/4 of the chips has any cheese on them."
"The wings had no seasoning on them (very bland), and had a bunch of butter, and shredded parm cheese dumped on top of them."
"The food looks great but it was mostly all very bland."