Liberty Bagels Wall Street Reviews Summary

Category: Bakery New York

Address: 32 Broadway, New York, NY 10004, USA

Phone: +12123811290

Rating: 4.5
based on 195 reviews.

Bagel Quality

Pros:

  • "One of, if not, the finest bagels I’ve had."
  • "SUCH GOOD BAGELS OMG! The cutest place and best bagels."
  • "The rainbow bagels it’s really good and worth to try because it’s taste of vanilla."
  • "Great bagels with incredible toppings and lots of good cream cheese flavors!"
  • "Hands down the best bagels in New York."
  • "The bagels are huge, barely fitting into a toaster when sliced in half. The chewy texture is satisfying, and they toast nicely."
  • "The bagels here are always fresh, chewy, and perfectly toasted, with a wide variety of toppings and spreads to choose from."

Cons:

  • "honestly, this bagel doesn't even compare to Leo's Bagels."
  • "Worst bagels."
  • "Unfortunately. the poppy bagel for this branch was really tough to chew."
  • "The bagel was a bit too dense, and the cream cheese was too sweet."
  • "Not my favorite bagel and was pretty overpriced in my opinion."
  • "When I bit into it it didn’t taste fresh and was very stale. Hard almost."
  • "sorry to report that bagel is just not that good. feels dense and underbaked."

Customer Service

Pros:

  • "Vinny the owner is the absolute nicest fella."
  • "I was immediately amazed with service."
  • "The cashier Victor was very helpful and he had a great smile that made me want to come back."
  • "Staff was very friendly and knowledgeable and glad to give recommendations."
  • "These guys are awesome! Not only the bagels were a staple piece in our trip but the service was without a doubt a 10/10."
  • "The staff were very friendly and nice."
  • "Walked into this location and was immediately greeted by their friendly staff."

Cons:

  • "Hard to find spots to sit."
  • "Rude customer service (a young girl with dark hair was with 2 other people behind the billing counters)."
  • "She had a mocking tone when saying those words. It wasn’t very nice."
  • "As usual, the cashiers and staff aren’t the friendliest."
  • "Please fire this girl. She doesn't deserve a job."
  • "There were long queues nevertheless and one person inside shouting at everyone to stand here and there."
  • "After being asked why they closed 40 min early he responded with 'they made enough money today'."

Seating & Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "There’s tables inside if you’d want to dine in."
  • "The cozy atmosphere is perfect for grabbing a quick breakfast or lunch."
  • "The place was very busy but had lots of seating."
  • "Plenty of seating for coworkers, friend groups, and family trips!"
  • "This cozy spot offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere that feels like a little escape from the bustling streets outside."
  • "Awesome environment, hospitable staff, and plenty of room to sit down and enjoy your meal."
  • "The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make you feel right at home, setting the stage for an unforgettable bagel experience."

Cons:

  • "Most likely there will not be a place to sit inside."
  • "The tables were unclean, we had to clean them up."
  • "I wasn’t particularly satisfied with the seating."
  • "I didn’t dine in because there wasn’t a lot of space and the tables were cluttered with families and babies."
  • "Not much space to sit and eat."
  • "The service is a bit weird since you have to take the coupon inside and then walk near the entrance for coffee and the food counters are spread out, this arrangement is weird."
  • "Wayyyyy to much cream cheese being in the city everything is a fast paced."

Price & Value

Pros:

  • "Fair prices for bagels. You can get a good bagel with cheese starting around 3$."
  • "Great food for a good price."
  • "The food was incredible and I would guess there was enough food for twice as many!"
  • "Fed a family of 5 for $30 and my kids thought it was the greatest thing since sliced, well, bagels."
  • "I paid $5 for the bagel with cream cheese, but it was delicious!"
  • "The price was nice and affordable."
  • "Price seemed reasonable."

Cons:

  • "Don’t waste $15 here."
  • "This sandwich cost 8 to 10 bucks and for that I should have received more bacon."
  • "It’s fairly priced at seven dollars for a bagel with two slices of tomatoes is a bit overpriced."
  • "Not my favorite bagel and was pretty overpriced in my opinion."
  • "The bagels are insanely good, a bit pricey but definitely worth it."
  • "I just feel like a bagel with just cream cheese (even if it's the fancier flavors) shouldn't cost you more than $5 or maybe $7 max."
  • "I ended up paying $9 for a jalapeño bagel and chive cream cheese."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.