Emmett's Reviews Summary

Category: Pizza restaurant New York

Address: 50 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012, USA

Phone: +19176393571

Rating: 4.5
based on 221 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The garlic cheesy bread was magnificent."
  • "They are known for their deep dish but it was the thin crust slices that made our night."
  • "Got the meat lovers deep dish and this was delicious!"
  • "The deep dish pizza is fabulous: quality toppings (for us was the meat lover so pepperoni, Italian beef, sausage) and the crust of the dough is amazing."
  • "First time ever having deep dish and this exceeded every expectation I had."
  • "The pizza was amazingly delicious especially for its crispy & crunchy crust and melty cheese."
  • "Deep dish very good. Particularly enjoyed the crust, not hard or soggy."

Cons:

  • "Our thin pizza had sesame sead sized gravel in it... complained to the server who said it was cornmeal."
  • "The cheese fries as an appetizer, which were honestly a disappointment - the cheese felt like it was haphazardly thrown on there and the cheese itself tasted like that powdered cheese in macaroni and cheese boxes."
  • "The ingredients - cheese & sauce - could've been fresher."
  • "I honestly thought this pizza was wack. Overpriced, mad saucy, not enough cheese, took too long, and seems overly pretentious in terms of the patrons."
  • "The only thing that’s disappointing was the little ingredients inside, which was not enough for us."
  • "The day I went I was served with undercooked dough with very good quality toppings."
  • "The pizza is just . . Not flavorful."

Service

Pros:

  • "Staff is friendly and the 80s vibe is great without feeling manufactured."
  • "The bartender took excellent care of us."
  • "The staff is super friendly, welcoming, and professional!"
  • "The service was good. Waiter was friendly and helpful."
  • "The staff were friendly and had conversations with us till we waited for the pizza."
  • "Helpful and friendly staff."
  • "Friendly, knowledgeable servers, fantastic food and great ambiance makes for an intimate and delicious dining experience."

Cons:

  • "It's so inauthentic that it feels like taking advantage of people expecting an authentic Chicago experience."
  • "Service seems a bit better than last time but the young dude is really forgetful given he is in his 20s!"
  • "The check arrive wrong, they charge us a more expensive wine that the one we ask for and a 10% covid recovery fee (they don’t measure temperature, overcapacity and no sanitizer)."
  • "Really disappointed with our visit to Emmett's last week due to poor service and cold/raw food."
  • "Came to pick up an order for delivery and the employees at the front desk are super rude, not friendly and racist."
  • "The staff was awfully rude, they told us the wait was an hour but we waited an hour and a half."
  • "While I was paying and leaving a tip, he was again rude, sighing loudly."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere decor and the building has a warm vintage feel."
  • "It’s an extremely cute and quaint restaurant, with a great atmosphere and vibe."
  • "Very cool atmosphere in there with great music."
  • "Nice vibe as well. Right in the middle of everything."
  • "Cozy atmosphere, good music, friendly service."
  • "The atmosphere is cozy--quiet enough to converse easily but still lively."
  • "Vibe is chill, cozy, friendly."

Cons:

  • "The restaurant is a little snug for me and my claustrophobic."
  • "So crowded that I could barely get in."
  • "The place is a tucked away and a bit small but don't let the location fool you."
  • "Most small places are loud, and Emmett's is no exception."
  • "My main gripe with this place is the lighting. It's dim, too dim for my liking."
  • "Sitting in a small cramped cold restaurant in SoHo waiting 45 minutes for Chicago pizza is a lot to ask for."
  • "It's also very tight in the main store. Feels like there are too many tables."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.