2 Bros Pizza Reviews Summary

Category: Pizza restaurant New York

Address: 557 8th Ave, New York, NY 10018, USA

Phone: +16469164541

Rating: 4.3
based on 252 reviews.

Price and Value

Pros:

  • "$3 for two slices of pizza and a can of soda (with tax included in the price)? Can't beat that."
  • "All I got was four slices of their 'one dollar per slice' cheese pizza and that’s enough to earn them five stars."
  • "For only $1 (tax included) you get fresh pizza that you really won't be disappointed."
  • "Best value for money! Very good ORIGINAL NYC style pizza."
  • "2 slices and a soda for $3.99 so close to Times Square - great value."
  • "For the price ($1 for a cheese slice), this is just about the best you'll find."
  • "Their 2 cheese slices and a can of soda deal for $2.99 is unbeatable!"

Cons:

  • "Price is really low, but the pizza quality is too. Really oily and flavorless."
  • "They accept debit cards with purchases over $5.....actually illegal....and a big turn off for someone who doesn't need $5 worth of 2 Bros.....shady business ethics."
  • "The only reason I can imagine anyone giving this joint getting more than one star would be that it's super cheap."
  • "You get what you paid for and I definitely do not recommend due the how the staff handles food without following Department of Health standards."
  • "Even after 10 beers I couldn’t eat it."
  • "The pizza wasn’t great like the other pizza I had at 1435 Broadway."
  • "The pineapple pizza’s ham tasted like it came out of a lunchable and the pineapple tasted old and flavorless."

Service and Staff

Pros:

  • "The service was fast and efficient, so I was able to get my food quickly and get on with my day."
  • "The turnover rate is great so you’ve got fresh pie."
  • "I was truly impressed with the speed and efficiency of the employees."
  • "Treat others how you want to be treated & you will be treated amazing! Very polite workers."
  • "The staff is very friendly and fast."
  • "The service was prompt and friendly, adding to the overall positive experience."
  • "Service is quick and friendly."

Cons:

  • "Many times I've seen customers order from here and were belittled in Spanish by the staff."
  • "Never EVER have I popped in for a slice where the staff was SO INSUFFERABLY RUDE."
  • "Not all staff than serves food wear plastic gloves, nor hair nets."
  • "The staff seems a bit detached."
  • "Service was terrible. 5 of us in group. As soon as 2 ordered, ignored the rest of the group."
  • "The employees were terrible and tried to rob us if $20."
  • "The guy at the counter was very unprofessional! As a veteran to be treated like that is terrible!"

Quality and Taste

Pros:

  • "The pizza base they make is probably the best available in NYC at that price."
  • "Easily the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life and it’s so cheap too."
  • "2 Bros Pizza serves one of the best pizza that I've tested in Manhattan."
  • "Pizza is crispy and doughy but just the right amount of both."
  • "The crust, the cheese, perfect."
  • "The pizza tasted absolutely fantastic, especially the veggie one we always go for."
  • "The crust was crispy and flavorful, the sauce was perfectly seasoned, and the cheese was melted to perfection."

Cons:

  • "This place makes people hate pizza."
  • "The pizza isn't as tasty as Don Pepi's Pizza in Penn Station but it is still very solid by non-NYC standards."
  • "Some of the worst dollar pizza you can get in the area."
  • "Price is really low, but the pizza quality is too. Really oily and flavorless."
  • "The cheese slices were just decent. This place seems to use canned tomato sauce without a lot of flavor."
  • "The pizza itself? Considering that the people behind the counter are NOT Italian, it's ok."
  • "The pizza was too cold to truly enjoy and we only liked 2 out of 5 varieties we tried."

Atmosphere and Location

Pros:

  • "It is a nice place to grab a relatively quick meal to eat on the go."
  • "Loved the atmosphere of the people around just waiting for their turn to order."
  • "Being close to Penn station serves an advantage for regular commuters."
  • "2 Bros Pizza was outstanding and open late in Time Square."
  • "The atmosphere of the restaurant was also very welcoming and friendly."
  • "For those exploring Times Square on a budget, this pizza place is a gem worth discovering."
  • "If you want a true NYC experience, COME HERE!"

Cons:

  • "Only seats about six people. So don't plan on taking a group here to eat in."
  • "It's not wheelchair accessible."
  • "The atmosphere was a bit sketchy though, lots of loitering around it and it’s a bit smelly on the outskirts."
  • "Solo women shouldn't make that walk alone from Times Square since it was about 1 or 2 blocks along a dark path."
  • "Not too many seats Beggars asking for money sometimes hanging around."
  • "Very small location, if busy there is no where to sit."
  • "A punk place, which is not clean at all. The tables are meant for children and are very filthy with stickers and graffiti everywhere."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.