"$3 for two slices of pizza and a can of soda (with tax included in the price)? Can't beat that."
"All I got was four slices of their 'one dollar per slice' cheese pizza and that’s enough to earn them five stars."
"For only $1 (tax included) you get fresh pizza that you really won't be disappointed."
"Best value for money! Very good ORIGINAL NYC style pizza."
"2 slices and a soda for $3.99 so close to Times Square - great value."
"For the price ($1 for a cheese slice), this is just about the best you'll find."
"Their 2 cheese slices and a can of soda deal for $2.99 is unbeatable!"
Cons:
"Price is really low, but the pizza quality is too. Really oily and flavorless."
"They accept debit cards with purchases over $5.....actually illegal....and a big turn off for someone who doesn't need $5 worth of 2 Bros.....shady business ethics."
"The only reason I can imagine anyone giving this joint getting more than one star would be that it's super cheap."
"You get what you paid for and I definitely do not recommend due the how the staff handles food without following Department of Health standards."
"Even after 10 beers I couldn’t eat it."
"The pizza wasn’t great like the other pizza I had at 1435 Broadway."
"The pineapple pizza’s ham tasted like it came out of a lunchable and the pineapple tasted old and flavorless."
Service and Staff
Pros:
"The service was fast and efficient, so I was able to get my food quickly and get on with my day."
"The turnover rate is great so you’ve got fresh pie."
"I was truly impressed with the speed and efficiency of the employees."
"Treat others how you want to be treated & you will be treated amazing! Very polite workers."
"The staff is very friendly and fast."
"The service was prompt and friendly, adding to the overall positive experience."
"Service is quick and friendly."
Cons:
"Many times I've seen customers order from here and were belittled in Spanish by the staff."
"Never EVER have I popped in for a slice where the staff was SO INSUFFERABLY RUDE."
"Not all staff than serves food wear plastic gloves, nor hair nets."
"The staff seems a bit detached."
"Service was terrible. 5 of us in group. As soon as 2 ordered, ignored the rest of the group."
"The employees were terrible and tried to rob us if $20."
"The guy at the counter was very unprofessional! As a veteran to be treated like that is terrible!"
Quality and Taste
Pros:
"The pizza base they make is probably the best available in NYC at that price."
"Easily the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life and it’s so cheap too."
"2 Bros Pizza serves one of the best pizza that I've tested in Manhattan."
"Pizza is crispy and doughy but just the right amount of both."
"The crust, the cheese, perfect."
"The pizza tasted absolutely fantastic, especially the veggie one we always go for."
"The crust was crispy and flavorful, the sauce was perfectly seasoned, and the cheese was melted to perfection."
Cons:
"This place makes people hate pizza."
"The pizza isn't as tasty as Don Pepi's Pizza in Penn Station but it is still very solid by non-NYC standards."
"Some of the worst dollar pizza you can get in the area."
"Price is really low, but the pizza quality is too. Really oily and flavorless."
"The cheese slices were just decent. This place seems to use canned tomato sauce without a lot of flavor."
"The pizza itself? Considering that the people behind the counter are NOT Italian, it's ok."
"The pizza was too cold to truly enjoy and we only liked 2 out of 5 varieties we tried."
Atmosphere and Location
Pros:
"It is a nice place to grab a relatively quick meal to eat on the go."
"Loved the atmosphere of the people around just waiting for their turn to order."
"Being close to Penn station serves an advantage for regular commuters."
"2 Bros Pizza was outstanding and open late in Time Square."
"The atmosphere of the restaurant was also very welcoming and friendly."
"For those exploring Times Square on a budget, this pizza place is a gem worth discovering."
"If you want a true NYC experience, COME HERE!"
Cons:
"Only seats about six people. So don't plan on taking a group here to eat in."
"It's not wheelchair accessible."
"The atmosphere was a bit sketchy though, lots of loitering around it and it’s a bit smelly on the outskirts."
"Solo women shouldn't make that walk alone from Times Square since it was about 1 or 2 blocks along a dark path."
"Not too many seats Beggars asking for money sometimes hanging around."
"Very small location, if busy there is no where to sit."
"A punk place, which is not clean at all. The tables are meant for children and are very filthy with stickers and graffiti everywhere."