Prince Street Pizza Reviews Summary

Price

Pros:

• "Each slice is about $7 but I got there at 2:30 am the second time they charged only $5 cuz I guess they were closing in 30 min!"
• "The slices are about $7/8 and worth every dollar — this is a must when I visit nyc."
• "A little pricy but definitely worth a try!!!"

Cons:

• "However, at $8 a slice, the expectations are different."
• "Lady told me two slices was $27."
• "Just want to note, the pizza is quite expensive for what it is."
• "$7.08 for 1 slice of their iconic spicy pepperoni, while delicious, has become too much for me to bear."
• "Most pizza’s are around $35ish dollars, we ordered a four cheese pizza and it was $54, shameful to charge this price!"
• "$30 for 4 slices is wild, especially for a place with nowhere to sit."
• "I order 2 slices and 1 water and they tried to charge me over $25 lol."

Service

Pros:

• "Customer service was great."
• "The queue moves quite quickly and the staff are efficient with little pleasantries."
• "Service was nice and quick, line was moving even on a saturday night."
• "All the staff are friendly!"
• "The staff is very nice and friendly."
• "Really great staff running this place. It was fun to chat with the fellas that were handling the rush."
• "Amazing hours and fantastic fantastic staff! Employees of the century."

Cons:

• "No one smiled and they barely looked at me."
• "The cashier was pretty rude."
• "Amazing tasting pizza but every time I go here the service is terrible."
• "The man taking orders was quite curt and rude."
• "We witnessed a customer being overcharged with a pick up offer and both the counter person and manager were both very rude to him."
• "Didn’t like the staff tho, extremely panicky and rude, they rush you to get your order very quickly."
• "Their attitude sucks, pizza is lukewarm, and they won't even greet you as you buy your 'discounted' NYC slice."

Quality

Pros:

• "The crust strikes the ideal balance between chewy and crispy, providing the perfect foundation for the savory toppings."
• "The pepperoni slices are a must-try; they’re crispy, savory, and full of flavor."
• "More than the dough, their unique sauce and cheese combo make the slice what it is."
• "Each bite is an explosion of savory goodness, from the delightful tomato sauce to the melty cheese."
• "The crust, the cheese is so fresh, light and delicious."
• "The crust is crispy on the outside yet soft and fluffy on the inside."
• "The pizza dough itself was crispy at the bottom and fluffy on the inside."

Cons:

• "The quality of my pizza was horrible. Old and soggy."
• "The regular cheese one wasn’t that great and I wouldn’t get it again."
• "My main issue with the slice itself is that the crust was unpleasantly dense and felt undercooked."
• "The pepperoni square pizza was a little under cooked. And it was breaking apart."
• "The four cheese was very bland and didn’t have any sauce, which made it dry."
• "The crust was average. The cheese was average."
• "The pizza itself was on average fine - the margarita and vodka pizzas were fire, the vegetable was notably underwhelming."