Barnwood Grill Reviews Summary

Category: New American restaurant

Address: 2 Old Tomahawk St, Yorktown Heights, NY 10598, USA

Phone: +19142488100

Rating: 4.6
based on 124 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food was delicious with a large menu to choose from."
  • "The Butternut squash ravioli are exquisite."
  • "The food was excellent, appetizers main course and desert."
  • "Tasty food, large portions, food presentation was great and quickly cooked."
  • "I was especially excited about the calamari. It was soft and seasoned perfectly!"
  • "The food is top notch, well made, and delicious."
  • "The food was really excellent from the flatbread to the burger and chicken salad all the way to the lemonade."

Cons:

  • "There was so much salt that it was uneatable."
  • "a Mac and Cheese that could be found in a box, with a cheese that was very clearly from a package"
  • "a pappardelle that was served in a watery sauce that tasted like it came from a can"
  • "The tuna was not seasoned at all, barely seared so super rare - like cold inside."
  • "The chicken wings were just okay."
  • "Both pieces of salmon were so overcooked and dry."
  • "Much of the food was bland."

Service

Pros:

  • "The effort by the wait staff was appreciated."
  • "They were so attentive service-wise, so accommodating with decor and set up."
  • "Our server Alti was sweet and attentive."
  • "Servers strike just the right tone: personable, professional, attentive, efficient, never obtrusive."
  • "Service was great all the dudes were very attentive and just kicking butt."
  • "Service was attentive and polite without being intrusive."
  • "The servers were attentive, and the manager was extremely helpful and kind."

Cons:

  • "However, we were slow to be seated, even with a reservation."
  • "Bar server was not happy that table service patrons were requesting mostly cocktails from x special menu."
  • "I made a reservation for 7:45 & arrived on time but it took 15 min for the owner to greet us."
  • "Sat at the bar and bar server was not happy that table service patrons were requesting mostly cocktails from x special menu."
  • "He had asked for medium rare and when we got the steak parts of it were legit raw."
  • "I say at the bar 10 minutes prior to end of happy hour and wasn't approached until 3 minutes AFTER happy hour ended and was refused the happy hour pricing."
  • "It took 20 minutes for her to arrive (I timed it)."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere was very welcoming."
  • "Quaint Country Decor."
  • "Great atmosphere, friendly staff and phenomenal food!"
  • "The atmosphere and staff are always warm and welcoming."
  • "Place was clean and atmosphere was nice."
  • "Atmosphere is very friendly and on point."
  • "The ambiance was beautiful as well!"

Cons:

  • "Customers were old depressing nasty wastes of oxygen, really putrid people."
  • "Tables jammed together."
  • "Tables jammed together... Felt rushed at the end."
  • "Very loud in main dining area."
  • "Outdoor seating was available but covered in snow?"
  • "The only minus is when the restaurant gets full it gets very loud in the dining area."
  • "I found the ribs to be dry any scantly covered in meat."

Value

Pros:

  • "Great selection of craft beers, whiskey's, Bourbons scotches and mix drinks."
  • "I enjoyed the price fixed meal... app, salad, dinner and dessert for $30. Great value."
  • "found the prices for lunch entrees reasonable"
  • "The prices were not cheap but not expensive either, pretty much in the middle."
  • "It was sort of reasonably priced."
  • "The food surprised me and was really good."
  • "The food is fun and fresh and thoughtfully prepared."

Cons:

  • "Disastrous Mother’s Day dinner. Bad/overpriced food/service."
  • "I felt it was a bit pricey and probably a little short on the portions."
  • "Wine was overpriced for the selection offered."
  • "way over priced."
  • "2 appetizers that were over cooked and way over priced."
  • "It's a little pricey so we will be there for special occasions."
  • "Was charged $14 for the two of us, thought that was high."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.