Chez Nick Reviews Summary

Category: New American restaurant New York

Address: 1737 York Ave, New York, NY 10128, USA

Phone: +16464293310

Rating: 4.6
based on 133 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Went to Chez Nick on a whim and it was delicious."
  • "The food is amazing!!!"
  • "Everything we tried was amazing, reasonably priced, will definitely come back."
  • "The food is always first class."
  • "The soft fluffiness of the Dutch pancake, and the exquisite flavors of the ricotta toast are SUPERB!"
  • "All were super fresh and full of flavor."
  • "One of the best meals I’ve ever had! The brussel sprouts, falafel, duck ragout, and octopus were incredible."

Cons:

  • "The experience was horrible... We had to wait almost 40min to have our food served."
  • "The fried chicken and waffles was terrible. Two tiny pieces with burnt waffles dipped in some rancid mixture of cheap quality maple syrup/ butter."
  • "The contents of the glass jar had a very strange taste, nothing like chicken liver."
  • "The 'supposedly' clean unused fork had distinct fishy smell and I had to return it for another one."
  • "The food comes with add ons that are not on the menu, which is very frustrating."
  • "The tahini carrots, beets & burrata and calamari pasta were underwhelming and not very tasty."
  • "So ridiculously overpriced, and really average food."

Service

Pros:

  • "The manager Joe talked about the restaurant week menu with us, he was super attentive and kind."
  • "The service was great. They didn't rush us and was very courteous and professional."
  • "Genuinely welcoming and friendly staff."
  • "Our server was fantastic."
  • "The service is exceptional (thank you to our awesome hostess Laura and waitress Carly)."
  • "The staff is very attentive, food is delicious and the drinks are out of this world."
  • "The staff was so friendly and accommodating and everything we ate was delicious."

Cons:

  • "The vibe of the restaurant is wonderful, but you will have 10 flies buzzing around you while you sit indoors."
  • "But have to note that one bartender has consistently put forth a sub par effort."
  • "However, tonight the service was poor."
  • "Service is friendly if a little spotty (sometimes you sit with a delivered meal without being checked or with an empty drink)."
  • "It took quite a while for them to come collect the order and even much longer to serve the food (or drinks)."
  • "Glacial is the best way to describe the speed of service and food preparation."
  • "Unfortunately, the music was too loud."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere was cozy and relaxed with what appeared to be many regular locals."
  • "The restaurant was nicely decorated but still comfortable to show up to in everyday clothes."
  • "Chez Nick is an absolute neighborhood gem, the place you just want to pop into every night for the best drink, best bites, and best atmosphere."
  • "Atmosphere is airy and bright."
  • "The ambiance is low key but classy, and most importantly all of the food is consistently amazing!"
  • "The airy setting and the friendly staff made our first restaurant visit after the lockdown a great experience."
  • "The ambience is fresh, bright, and cheerful."

Cons:

  • "Outside hut is a little chilly in the winter even with heaters because the seats are metal and vented."
  • "First off, the space has the worst noise issue ever! It was impossible to have a decent conversation!"
  • "The Dutch baby was not what I expected... The whole thing was about 2 inches thick and about 7 inches wide."

Value

Pros:

  • "Everything we tried was amazing, reasonably priced, will definitely come back."
  • "The absolute best thing about this restaurant is the value. The prices look a bit daunting but the value is great!"
  • "Compared to the area this place’s prices are reasonable."
  • "I highly recommend this restaurant for a delicious yet relatively inexpensive meal in an excellent atmosphere with impeccable service."
  • "Reasonable price points."

Cons:

  • "Overall, the portion (especially the sides) felt rather small for what I paid."
  • "Disappointed with the small serving of salmon at dinner."
  • "My one gripe is that my cold brew was so small! Felt like it was 5 sips total."
  • "So ridiculously overpriced, and really average food."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.