The Cabin NYC Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Food was really really good, and priced pretty well."
• "The truffle fries and burrata were also soooooo freaking good."
• "The food was very delicious, especially the Biggie biscuit and gravy for the Throwback Brunch on the weekends."
• "The Angus beef burger was delicious and juicy. One of the best burgers I've ever ate."
• "The chicken and waffles are amazing."
• "The food is out of this world!!! The waffles, the PAC potatoes & eggs are to die for."
• "Every item was divine and the ingredients in each dish all went together so deliciously."

Cons:

• "Food was okay but overpriced."
• "The food was very disappointing. I ordered the chicken and waffles and the chicken was dry!"
• "Their burrito was sad."
• "5 of us got sick from the food and the food comes out 1 at a time."
• "Really cute atmosphere but the food was bad."
• "Food was meh."
• "The food was just okay. Nothing really spectacular."

Service

Pros:

• "Our server was attentive, honest, and very friendly."
• "The servers was terrific I felt like I was home eating."
• "Christina, the server/host was amazing."
• "Staff was super nice."
• "The owners and staff were very attentive and kept coming to check up on our table to see how everything was going.. love love love that!"
• "Every single waitress/hostess that approached/served us was so sweet and helpful and made sure we got everything we needed!"
• "Kristina is one of the best servers/bartenders I’ve ever had."

Cons:

• "We definitely will NOT be coming back to this establishment."
• "The staff here are rude and they are liars."
• "The server was rude and we had 4 dirty glasses that had clear lipstick marks on them."
• "Spotty service just really set it over the edge, with inattentive servers."
• "We noticed the bartender didn't even bother making our drinks & only focused on his bar guests."
• "The server apologized for the wait & asked the bartender again to make our drinks, & he still didn't."
• "The door lady next door for The Cabin was so incredibly rude."

Ambiance

Pros:

• "Great spot for awesome drinks and and amazing decor and ambiance for great selfies and unique shots for your Instagram feed."
• "There is also a really cute swing photo op that is very fall!!!"
• "The decor and vibe was amazing- great albeit slightly too loud music."
• "Beautiful decorations to satisfy your photogenic soul. Happy vibe on a Christmas night."
• "A beautiful rustic cabin interior. Cozy and romantic seating and bar."
• "Such a beautiful rustic restaurant."
• "The overall vibe and ambiance was so relaxing and cozy with a hint of romance."

Cons:

• "The instagram-y picture nook between the commodes is kinda comical in 2024."
• "We were seated outdoors in the ‘cabin’ (plastic tent). It was freezing cold."
• "Unfortunately we didn't have a good experience. The food was not good, the music was too loud."
• "It's unique, but ultimately feels gimmicky and kind of downmarket to me."
• "Wasn’t a big fan of the very loud speaker over our table."
• "Walking in was like a whimsical forest of trees and flowers."
• "The atmosphere is both classy and cozy."

Drinks

Pros:

• "Drinks are $15-17 each."
• "Their specialty cocktails were flavorful but do not leave you feeling tipsy."
• "We also got two cocktails that were really good!"
• "The house old-fashioned is super delicious - they are rightfully proud of their cocktails."
• "For drinks, I would highly recommend their Campfire Old Fashioned."
• "The drinks were also good, strong, and cheap!"
• "The drinks were delicious, the food was unbelievable, the atmosphere was comforting, and everyone around us seemed to be having a great time."

Cons:

• "I had no buzz after 3 of them."
• "The drinks are all super sweet and watered down."
• "The cocktails were so tasteless."
• "I ordered a Bloody Mary, and it was pretty subpar."
• "The drink menu was really well thought out for the season."
• "The food.. it's like the menu is designed to give you diabetes. EVERYTHING is covered in or seasoned with SUGAR."
• "The Spiked hot apple cider is absolutely phenomenal!"