Address: 269 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023, USA
Phone: +16468700810
Rating: 4.3
based on 164 reviews.
Service
Pros:
"The service was absolutely impeccable and the food (and cocktails!!) delicious and the pricing more than reasonable compared to anything around here."
"The best service I’ve ever had in NYC!!!"
"Service was really good, servers were so friendly and actually looked like they were having fun."
"The service alone earned five stars! This cozy little place is charming and welcoming."
"Very fresh and delicious food, exceptional service."
"The staff and service were amazing."
"Service was great and food was absolutely delicious."
Cons:
"Wait staff seem overworked."
"The server was very nice but could have been a more attentive."
"We spent a long time waiting for someone to come by with menus and offer us water."
"Service was good, but the food left a bit to be desired."
"Service was abysmal. Had to get up numerous times to find our waitperson in a very uncrowded restaurant."
"The service was absolutely awful."
"However, it still gets quite warm in the summer and they said they Keep the AC off."
Food Quality
Pros:
"Delicious lunch salads and bowls like the spinach and soba noodle salad with protein — creative and filling while reasonably priced."
"Great food. Really diverse menu with lots of vegan, vegetarian, and fish options."
"The Miso glazed Tuna was awesome."
"The kimchi burger with the black bean burger and lettuce wrap was absolutely amazing!!!"
"Their guacamole was voted one of the four best guacamoles in the U.S. by the Huffington Post."
"Very tasty New American food, fresh salad, homemade fries, very fast and really delicious."
"DELICIOUS burgers and high quality food every single time."
Cons:
"Food was decent. It’s not bad, not great, just decent."
"Thoroughly mediocre food."
"Overcooked eggs, a 'biscuit' the size of my pinky finger, wilted salad and an ungodly amount of bacon made up my country breakfast meal."
"Food, was mediocre to fine. Several of us had fish tacos which were miserly portions and overcooked and rubbery."
"food is below average. lobster roll was strangely spice and “old bay” fries didnt have any old bay on them."
"The food was not anything special."
"Brussels sprouts were soggy and pretty terrible."
Ambience
Pros:
"It's a lovely place with lots of dining options."
"Always a pleasure being here. Really lovely decor, great retro music, very laid back yet very grown-up."
"The inside of the restaurant is very clean & comfortable."
"The cocktail lounge in the back is stunning, and we love the new bar area."
"The atmosphere was also relaxing with nice music and the cute interior."
"It’s got a great welcoming vibe and offers outdoor seating as well."
"The atmosphere was great sitting on the patio as well."
Cons:
"The only downside, besides the host, everyone was just blah in being welcoming."
"The only thing is there is a step up going to the bar that should be painted a bright color. It's trip able."
"Sunday noon so crowded and noisy we could not have a decent conversation."
"Glazed glass and curtains claustrophobic."
"However, it still gets quite warm in the summer and they said they Keep the AC off."
"I wished they covered their 4th wall (even partially) so that it was warmer."
"No management in sight. Nobody overseeing the ebb and flow of the room."
Value
Pros:
"The food was good (we had the porc tacos (I don't remember the exact name) and the lime thyme chicken) and we were full."
"If you are looking for a great value then make it a point to dine at Harvest Kitchen!"
"The prices were reasonable if not a bit expensive at times."
"Prices were most defiantly reasonable."
"Our bill was under 40 dollars."
"They must get all their ingredients farm fresh since everything always tastes so fresh."
"Varied and healthy (if you want it) menu, but bacon, onion, and spinach frittata with salad on side was perfect and reasonably priced."
Cons:
"If you charge $29 for a steak, I would expect it to be good."
"One negative is if they are going to charge you for more than one refill of coffee, they should tell you in advance."
"Overpriced and underwhelming! My quinoa bowl dressing was too sour."
"The Lobster rolls are good but way overpriced."
"Tiramisu($10): a bit pricey for the portion but great taste."
"What a shame! We were hoping for a nice evening out but ended up very disappointed and $100 poorer."
"The service however was absolutely awful. Never in my life have a felt more justified in not leaving a tip."