HARVEST KITCHEN Reviews Summary

Category: New American restaurant New York

Address: 269 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023, USA

Phone: +16468700810

Rating: 4.3
based on 164 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "The service was absolutely impeccable and the food (and cocktails!!) delicious and the pricing more than reasonable compared to anything around here."
  • "The best service I’ve ever had in NYC!!!"
  • "Service was really good, servers were so friendly and actually looked like they were having fun."
  • "The service alone earned five stars! This cozy little place is charming and welcoming."
  • "Very fresh and delicious food, exceptional service."
  • "The staff and service were amazing."
  • "Service was great and food was absolutely delicious."

Cons:

  • "Wait staff seem overworked."
  • "The server was very nice but could have been a more attentive."
  • "We spent a long time waiting for someone to come by with menus and offer us water."
  • "Service was good, but the food left a bit to be desired."
  • "Service was abysmal. Had to get up numerous times to find our waitperson in a very uncrowded restaurant."
  • "The service was absolutely awful."
  • "However, it still gets quite warm in the summer and they said they Keep the AC off."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Delicious lunch salads and bowls like the spinach and soba noodle salad with protein — creative and filling while reasonably priced."
  • "Great food. Really diverse menu with lots of vegan, vegetarian, and fish options."
  • "The Miso glazed Tuna was awesome."
  • "The kimchi burger with the black bean burger and lettuce wrap was absolutely amazing!!!"
  • "Their guacamole was voted one of the four best guacamoles in the U.S. by the Huffington Post."
  • "Very tasty New American food, fresh salad, homemade fries, very fast and really delicious."
  • "DELICIOUS burgers and high quality food every single time."

Cons:

  • "Food was decent. It’s not bad, not great, just decent."
  • "Thoroughly mediocre food."
  • "Overcooked eggs, a 'biscuit' the size of my pinky finger, wilted salad and an ungodly amount of bacon made up my country breakfast meal."
  • "Food, was mediocre to fine. Several of us had fish tacos which were miserly portions and overcooked and rubbery."
  • "food is below average. lobster roll was strangely spice and “old bay” fries didnt have any old bay on them."
  • "The food was not anything special."
  • "Brussels sprouts were soggy and pretty terrible."

Ambience

Pros:

  • "It's a lovely place with lots of dining options."
  • "Always a pleasure being here. Really lovely decor, great retro music, very laid back yet very grown-up."
  • "The inside of the restaurant is very clean & comfortable."
  • "The cocktail lounge in the back is stunning, and we love the new bar area."
  • "The atmosphere was also relaxing with nice music and the cute interior."
  • "It’s got a great welcoming vibe and offers outdoor seating as well."
  • "The atmosphere was great sitting on the patio as well."

Cons:

  • "The only downside, besides the host, everyone was just blah in being welcoming."
  • "The only thing is there is a step up going to the bar that should be painted a bright color. It's trip able."
  • "Sunday noon so crowded and noisy we could not have a decent conversation."
  • "Glazed glass and curtains claustrophobic."
  • "However, it still gets quite warm in the summer and they said they Keep the AC off."
  • "I wished they covered their 4th wall (even partially) so that it was warmer."
  • "No management in sight. Nobody overseeing the ebb and flow of the room."

Value

Pros:

  • "The food was good (we had the porc tacos (I don't remember the exact name) and the lime thyme chicken) and we were full."
  • "If you are looking for a great value then make it a point to dine at Harvest Kitchen!"
  • "The prices were reasonable if not a bit expensive at times."
  • "Prices were most defiantly reasonable."
  • "Our bill was under 40 dollars."
  • "They must get all their ingredients farm fresh since everything always tastes so fresh."
  • "Varied and healthy (if you want it) menu, but bacon, onion, and spinach frittata with salad on side was perfect and reasonably priced."

Cons:

  • "If you charge $29 for a steak, I would expect it to be good."
  • "One negative is if they are going to charge you for more than one refill of coffee, they should tell you in advance."
  • "Overpriced and underwhelming! My quinoa bowl dressing was too sour."
  • "The Lobster rolls are good but way overpriced."
  • "Tiramisu($10): a bit pricey for the portion but great taste."
  • "What a shame! We were hoping for a nice evening out but ended up very disappointed and $100 poorer."
  • "The service however was absolutely awful. Never in my life have a felt more justified in not leaving a tip."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.