"Between great cocktails surprisingly delicious food and a nice ambience and experience from our server five out of five."
"Emmy has amazing deep dish pizzas, garlic bread and to die for waffle fries."
"Le Big Matt=perfect burger."
"The white pizza was my preferred one (bacon with pineapple and hot peppers)."
"The pizza was tasty and delicious. The top was saucy and flavorful with a nice satisfying crunchy crust."
"The pizza was fantastic too! The touch of honey made it really easy to eat - not that it needed it."
Cons:
"We got the Good Pauline which tasted simultaneously burnt and undercooked."
"The salad was a bit drab. And the pizza of all things was kind of dry."
"The Tina didn't have much flavor at all and was very bland; truthfully, I did not enjoy it because it was cold and flavorless."
"The Detroit Style pizza is tiny and not memorable in taste."
"The pizza... when it hit our table was clearly cold."
"The burger sauce was over seasoned."
"The pizza was good but not $25 good, not even $15 good."
Service
Pros:
"Stephanie hooked it up for us! She was so funny and kind all night."
"Stephanie the bartender and Joel the chef were so friendly and welcoming, they clearly cared that we had an amazing experience."
"Stephanie's service was amazing and very welcoming; honestly part of the reason we would come back."
"Had an amazing Birthday celebration with my family of 4 at Emmy Squared... friendly and very attentive servers/bartenders."
"Our server, Ariel, was as attentive as they come, anticipating our every need and making sure that we felt taken care of throughout the meal."
"The staff was courteous and let us know upon arrival that there would be additional waiting time."
"The service was incredible as well. Tiffany was our server and she was so attentive and friendly!"
Cons:
"Took 10 minutes of just sitting before the bartender took my order."
"The bartenders were careless in their work — throughout the night they kept spilling drinks, flinging water and alcohol all over our food, and continuously ignored us."
"The bartender ignored us for a good 20 minutes before we could get drinks, let alone order food."
"The waitress never checked on us and we realized that we were sitting there for almost an hour and our pizza never came out."
"Service was ATROCIOUS, it felt like we offended the service staff by waiting 55 minutes on top of the 90 minutes we were told the wait would be."
"When I went here a month ago I assumed the awful service was a fluke. However, upon going back I realized that the service is consistently awful."
"Customer service was lacking! Our pizza was brought out and we weren't provided plates or flatware."
Ambience
Pros:
"The restaurant had a dark and moody vibe going on. It would be great for a date night or late night hang out."
"Cute atmosphere as well!"
"Ambiance was cool-meets-casual."
"The restaurant had a great atmosphere."
"Loved the atmosphere in this place!"
"The ambience was great. The playlist they had on was good too."
"Cool spot for a date, family outing, anything really that’s why I like this place so much; very versatile."
Cons:
"While we were catching up the music was extremely loud and our table was directly under a speaker."
"They had a weird smell to the place."
"The ambiance is ok if you are upstairs, down stairs is a bit small and dark but better if u have kids and want less noise."
"It was 80% empty, and I still felt ignored the whole time."
"One of the pizzas was burnt on the top - it was completely charred, and should not have been served."
"The only issue we had last night was the hostess. She was fairly rude."
"When we arrived there were 2 other parties seated but no employees were anywhere to be seen."
Value
Pros:
"This is a well operated business with a quality product at a fare price."
"Overheard the table next to us complain about the high price for small pizza but it's totally worth the price."
"Prices are fairly reasonable."
"Very well priced food and drink menu."
"The pizza was prepared perfectly... crisp edges and just the right amount of sauce and toppings."
"The pizza and burger though are some of the absolute best in NY."
"The pizza was great, I couldn’t even think of getting a slice a other places in the area because my pizza cravings was completely satisfied."
Cons:
"It's pretty expensive for what you get."
"Ordered on UberEats - paid $30 for what is basically a personal pizza."
"$70 for two pizzas that are objectively very small is really, really expensive."
"That $25 burger is interesting... But that price is straight up OD, LOL."
"It's gotten truly expensive at an absurd level for pizza."
"A bit pricey $$$ A Double Stack Burger n Waffle fries $25."
"Including tax, $30 pizza? Who do these people think they are. RIPOFF"