Tenth Street Pasta & Pizza Reviews Summary

Pizza Quality

Pros:

• "Perfectly crispy pizza every time and the red sauce is sweet and tangy."
• "Pizza here has awesome sweet, garlicky red sauce, with freshly made mozzarella."
• "The crust is super crispy and cheesy, there is no such thing as getting a non desirable slice."
• "The square pie is one of the best pizzas I've ever had and you can feed 4-6 for 32 bucks. Can't beat it."
• "Truly amazing pizzas! I love with the square pie. Absolutely delicious and crunchy juicy crust on the sides."
• "The stand out topping was the pepperoni. This was not your bargain been cheapo roni this was top tier rounds of red flavor."
• "The plain pie made thin and crispy with their special garlic, pepper oil is absolutely some of the best pizza I've ever had!"

Cons:

• "The pizza came delivered completely burnt and inedible."
• "However, this time, the pizza was kinda burnt and overcooked, making the pizza dough/crust too crunchy."
• "Both came out with burnt edges and the rest is the most oil laden piece of dough you'll ever eat."
• "The texture of the pizza NOT good. It was spongy and hard to take a bite."
• "It’s a little burnt on the edges, it’s chewy, crispy, really oily, but it’s not really pizza — it’s flatbread with toppings."
• "Crust was close to burnt all round, very oily and no sauce or flavor, basically just quite disappointing."
• "Pizza was pretty sub par. Did not enjoy it at all."

Service

Pros:

• "Staff was super friendly and accommodating."
• "Great food and staff."
• "Service was perfect and the owner was a very nice and engaging guy."
• "The staff is so friendly they made us feel so comfortable and they kept checking on us making sure everything was great."
• "Great employees. Unmatched service. Great atmosphere."
• "Always fun to dine here and chat with Chris, Maria and staff."
• "A nice woman came out from the kitchen to check on us and was super kind to my daughter."

Cons:

• "Service is slightly slow but worth waiting for the crunchy crust!"
• "The service was awful! We finally got fed up and decided to go inside and ask what was the hold up."
• "Takeout is always very slow, but I've had experiences where they say the food will be ready in a half hour and it takes more than an hour."
• "The staff was avoidant and didn't tell us why there was such a long wait."
• "This girl gave me such attitude and tried to justify that it was just 'busy' and nothing she could do about the wait."
• "Service is also sub par. Took a long time to get our order taken."
• "Extremely poor service. We came tonight and we were totally ignored."

Value

Pros:

• "The square pie is one of the best pizzas I've ever had and you can feed 4-6 for 32 bucks. Can't beat it."
• "Our boys said it was the best pizza they had ever had. Friendly, reasonably priced and tasty."
• "BYOB which is a nice value add."
• "Also, BYOB which is a big plus."
• "It is a byob restaurant which makes the small space cozy and affordable."
• "They're BYOB so definitely bring yourself a nice bottle of wine or a 6 pack of something hoppy."
• "Don't forget to BYOB it."

Cons:

• "I must say this pizza was really good but a little pricey for a pie."
• "It cost $55 which is also just insane but #Hoboken and it's my birthday."
• "The prices here are laughable for the quality. It’s just okay pizza - nothing bad, but definitely not the best pizza around."
• "Also VERY expensive."
• "My real gripe is that we paid $85 for this after taxes and tip, which is absurd."
• "Only problem, and it’s not insignificant, are the prices. 2 two topping pizzas and a bottle of water was $83."
• "Too Overpriced."

Ambience

Pros:

• "Highly recommended when you’re in Hoboken!!!"
• "Great place for a quick bite, date night or group night out."
• "Love the small space and cozy atmosphere."
• "Love the decor, great vibe."
• "Incredible vibe and atmosphere."
• "Such a cute atmosphere and it's BYOB!"
• "It's a bit small, but it's cozy."