Category: Pizza restaurant Asbury Park, New Jersey
Address: 504 Main St, Asbury Park, NJ 07712, USA
Phone: +17328989000
Rating: 4.6
based on 111 reviews.
Food Quality
Pros:
"The food is consistently great."
"I strongly recommend if you are looking for creative food made with high quality ingredients."
"Believe the hype! Best mozzarella sticks that my wife and I have ever had."
"Their slices are so unique and delicious 😋. And 'THE WINGS' are 🔥🔥🔥."
"The mashed potatoes to die for. The chicken is so crispy and delightful."
"The rotisserie chicken, the BBQ wings and the garlic knots. Amazing!"
"Everything was flavorful!!"
Cons:
"The food was good but I guess I expected a little more flavor."
"The garlic knot part of the pizza was undercooked."
"Corn sadly flavorless bitter and inedible."
"Garlic knots too oily a hair undercooked but good flavor."
"Pizza was tasteless."
"The (Big Daddy) chicken wasn’t even cooked correctly."
"The 5 wings came out and were so over cooked they were dry and brittle, inedible."
Service
Pros:
"The staff were super helpful in taking the time to talk us through our order."
"Absolutely great atmosphere!"
"Service was good, all the staff were extremely friendly, as was the owner (manager? Guy in charge)"
"The staff is warm and friendly."
"Every time I walk in, I’m greeted with a hearty hello. and a genuine smile!"
"Joe really appreciates the business and it shows!"
"Joe and his crew were great and very accommodating. Service was quick."
Cons:
"First the employees weren't as friendly as advertised."
"Drinks came 30 minutes after we ordered."
"Wasn't allowed to go upstairs to eat with my daughter because it was an inconvenience for the lady working she was super rude."
"The waitress could care less offering a insincere, unprofessional 'my bad.'"
"The lady at the register, on the weekend, was super rude which even made me feel prejudice about what I eat!"
"the waiter rudely told us to pick another table."
"Promptly greeted, but getting our sodas took 15 mins and were delivered in takeout cups, my water came after 3 requests toward the end of our time there and in a real glass."
Value
Pros:
"Worth every dollar."
"Absolutely worth it. I cannot recommend the triple threat enough."
"Everything on his menu is super amazing hands-down an amazing guy and staff highly recommend stopping into Eating in or even order out."
"10/10 would recommend."
"Absolutely amazing. Even after our 4hr trip home they held up great."
"Was at my door in 30 minutes! Delicious pizza, can’t wait to order from here again."
"Best pizza on the shore! You Will NOT be Disappointed."
Cons:
"A PERSONAL 12” triple threat cost me nearly $40."
"This place ain't CHEAP just that alone was $50+."
"An extra-large buffalo chicken pie and a triple threat ended up being $75+ after tip. Not really worth it at that price."
"INSANELY OVERPRICED."
"$80 of food waste. For the price point, too many alternatives. We won’t be back."
"very pricey 38.00 and change for pizza and 2 glasses of coke."
"With $20+ cost for a personal pie, and a full size pie being almost $50, I don’t understand how people could even afford to go back."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"Plenty of room. Parking available on site in Asbury Park, so huge benefit."
"Absolutely great atmosphere!"
"The atmosphere was awesome."
"Atmosphere was so chill and so nicely decorated."
"It was a nice atmosphere. Staff was friendly as we walked into the restaurant."
"Loved the atmosphere, absolutely loved the food."
"The food and atmosphere was amazing."
Cons:
"The whole downstairs is used for pizza box storage and maybe 2 tables for a patron or two who might not want to climb the stairs, and a lot of wasted space to the back where the kitchen is."
"It was also very warm in there, it was not fun sweating the whole dinner."
"The omnipresent Bored Ape imagery and joker paintings are unsettling."
"Only open table was directly under the speaker of the tv."
"The place was messy with deliveries leaving the door open and bugs coming in."
"ZERO STARS. ABSOLUTELY AWFUL customer service from the 'chef'."