Mama's Meatballs & Pizzeria Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Got the regular cheese, Margherita, and legendary Leo and all three pizzas were absolutely delicious."
• "Meatballs? Obviously delicious."
• "Cheese steaks are amazing!"
• "The meatballs are delicious and the garlic knots are the best I ever had."
• "The best meatballs are in Jersey and I found them. Mama's Meatballs was absolutely fantastic."
• "The flatbread by itself can be a meal!"
• "The pizza? Delicious."

Cons:

• "I wanted to like it but the steak had no flavor was the wrong cheese very bland and the roll was more suited for a spaghetti dinner than a cheesesteak."
• "The taste was the worse I ever had for a meatball my husband thought the same."
• "Was craving both pizza and meatballs idk why?? This place was recommended, decided to come order a meatball pizza. Very greasy, floppy, not sure if the meatballs are stored in a pot with a juice- but that overtook the sauce."
• "The meatballs were a good size but very dry and didn't have much taste considering I ordered the Rocky Ballboa with sausage."
• "Pizza was soggy, and not much flavor in my opinion… if when you're holding your pizza slice and it flops and toppings sliding off then its a no go for me… uncooked and too much sauce.. sauce was also too sweet for me."
• "But the meatballs were a big disappointment. No flavor, no seasoning, no spice, just bland & flavorless."
• "I had the veggie meatballs but they were extremely salty."

Service

Pros:

• "Friendly employees."
• "The shop was really clean nobody was standing around everybody was working whether they were cleaning or filling orders."
• "The guy at the counter was really friendly and was talking to everyone that came in like he knew them."
• "The staff is friendly."
• "Great food and personnel."
• "Greeted as you walk in. Personable and friendly fast service and great food."
• "Service was phenomenal. Very polite and attentive."

Cons:

• "Don't understand the hype over this place. I ordered online and was given a wait time. When we got there, the wait time was 20 minutes longer than what the website said."
• "Having to wait 3x the quoted time for pick-up is angering and avoidable."
• "Awful wait times. Online said 55 min to pick up, then we waited another 45 in the lobby."
• "They close at 7 but if you walk in shortly before then, they tell you they aren't making anymore food."
• "If they don't need my business at 6:50, then they don't need my business any other time. Lazy."
• "Second time this happen I order my food and ask 'no onions'! last time I notice cause I ate the cheesesteak in the car and they remade it but they was about to close so the food ain’t had no flavor, this time I went home and they added onions to my cheesesteak again after I said no onions."
• "I requested no onions on everything yet they put onions on every single item I ordered."

Ambiance

Pros:

• "The shop was really clean nobody was standing around everybody was working whether they were cleaning or filling orders."
• "I enjoyed the music playing while waiting and seeing how the owner interacted with her customers."
• "Super Clean walking in. You have a straight shot of the kitchen and handling of your food."

Cons:

• "I've passed by this place hundreds of times I finally stopped in about 7:30 p.m. on 8/05/23 the atmosphere was a little dim could've been brighter."
• "Can't really eat in store other than a small table inside and the same outside."
• "More of a take out place but a few tables outside and a counter inside."